Now, perhaps I read into things but when she put her hair up with one of those things that girls use to tie their hair up, and judging by her eye contact and the way she was moving forward a little -- she was into me.
All I've gotta say is - Good Job!!! You were correct. When this happens, you have to move in for phone number. You weren't reading into it too much. One thing I must point out is some women are more difficult to read than others. Better to grab the number and give it a shot than getting nothing. You never know unless you take the chance.
That's always been my problem. Not initiating conversation, not in being cool or nice or even sexy. It's keeping the damn conversation going. My mind just can't take more than a few minutes talking to one girl. I either get kinda bored or don't want to "ruin a good thing" by saying something stupid. I just peeter out like some bad stock.
Who says you have to keep the conversation going? Once you have her interested, grab the number and bail out. Then set up a date. Dates are good for getting to know women better. Take full advantage of dating.