Searching... I could have written your post myself word for word. That's exactly how I feel. I only DA'd 4 months ago. At first, I found it comforting to read Crisis of Conscience and In Search of Christian Freedom. Those books helped me to let go of a lot of guilt for even leaving the Almighty Borg.
In the past several weeks, however, I'm finding that I am way too impressionable about religious or philosophical issues sometimes. Someone who feels strongly that there is a god, etc. can get me thinking 'Well, maybe they are right...'; then I talk to someone who is atheist or agnostic and again I start to think 'Well, maybe they're right...'. It can really make my brain hurt. After coming off of a 14 year "relationship" with the the borg, which doesn't allow you to think for yourself, it's hard for me to allow myself to think freely with no strings attached.
So - I have recently decided for myself that I'm not going to try to come up with answers of a deeply religious or philosophical nature for the time being. I'm putting myself on a religious "Leave of Absence" for an unspecified time. I intend to live life day to day, make decisions based on my own experience, education, morality, and instinct, and cross each bridge when I come to it. I respect what others believe, but I don't feel obligated to answer to anyone about what I believe or why. For the first time in my life, it's none of anyone else's business to know or make judgements about what I believe.
I would compare my "divorcing" the Watchtower similar to divorcing an abusive spouse. The last thing anyone "on the rebound" needs to do is to jump right into another bad relationship (religiously speaking). Allowing myself to not commit to specific beliefs at this point in my life is a huge weight off my shoulders. I figure that in the future when I'm ready to search deeper, the anwers will present themselves a little more clearly.