I was on the Beth Sarim JW reform site today and read some interesting threads from all sorts of folks, including some Bible Students (you know, of the ones that started off the watchtower but refused to follow the apostate Rutherford when he succeeded in his legal coup for control when Russell died). I never could understand the doctrine of the paradise earth hope, which the JWs seem to confuse with the millennial kingdom. Anyway, I stole a bit of someones post which I found interesting:
There is not one scripture that relegates the hope for those who follow Jesus in the narrow way to anything but heaven?
Can you show me one scripture where the New Testament Christians desired to live on a paradise earth? Can you show me one scripture where the apostles even preached a paradise earth for the Church? Just one scripture?
Can you show me a scripture that states that paradise earth is any sort of prize for the Christian Church?
I have never understood why despite the warnings in the New Testament about sticking to what Jesus described as this good news of the kingdom which will be preached to the whole world, the JWs preach a very different twentieth century version, about dates and a paradise earth. The Bible talks of an everlasting good news which is the basis for the faith that was once and for all time delivered to the holy ones.
2 John verse 9: If anyone does not remain in the teaching of Christ, but goes beyond it he does not have God with him....verse 10: if anyone comes to you bringing a different doctrine.....
I am astonished that you are so promptly turning away from the one who called you in the grace of Christ and are going over to a different gospel - not that there is another gospel....but even if we ourselves or even an angel from heaven preaches to you a gospel other than the one we preached to you, let Gods curse be on him. I repeat again wha we declared before; anyone who preaches to you a gospel other than the one you were first given is to be under Gods curse. ( Galatians 1:6-9 New Jerusalem Bible)