When Israel, as an organization, ;was abandoned by God, was it for the action of the collective, majority, or just the leadership? ; Who paid the price for that judgement? If the Watchtower society are the New Israel as they claim, are not their followers obliged to obey all their commands? ; What if even one of the commands coming from the Watchtower society is evil? ; Does not the organization itself become liable to judgement? ; If a follower disobeys his own conscience in favour of the collective, believing he is following Jehovah's commands, is he/she guilty of that sin, or the organization as a whole? Shunning is evil. ; It goes against a mother's nature to abandon her own child over doctrine (I am not talking gross evil here). ; If a mother overrides her good conscience, obeying rather the edicts of man, is she held, individually, accountable for the sin of abandonment? |
Jehovah's purpose was to save a people as a whole, not specific individuals. When natural Israel was lost, Jehovah ordained spiritual Israel as a whole (not the individuals within).
The Watchtower does not claim to be new Israel. The 144,000 as a whole is spiritual Israel. The ones on earth today are the faithful and discreet slave. They publish through the Watchtower publications. The "followers" or rather the congregtion members are obliged to obey as far as Heb 13:7 says " Remember those who are taking the lead among YOU , who have spoken the word of God to YOU , and as YOU contemplate how [their] conduct turns out imitate [their] faith." Notice that it does not say 'imitate their conduct' but rather imitate their faith.
Also Heb 13:17 "
17 Be obedient to those who are taking the lead among YOU and be submissive, for they are keeping watch over YOUR souls as those who will render an account; that they may do this with joy and not with sighing, for this would be damaging to YOU . "
So you state that if one of the commands from those taking the lead is evil, what should one do? Reading Heb 13:17. I don't see choices in there. But I do see that if they do bad, they will render the account. So Jehovah is looking for us to obey Heb 13:17. The reason being the damage to you is done from the joy that we can inhibit and the sighing that we can do.
Shunning is evil you say. You are correct in that a mother should not abandon her child. But that is not what is done (or at least supposed to be done as some will say 'they did this or that there') in the Christian congregation. But then again, isn't it also evil for a child to go against one's mother? Try looking at matters from both sides. That is what I am doing in this disertation. Why do you focus on the mother abandoning the child but not the actions of the child? It goes back to Heb 13:17, if the children are obedient to the parents then they can parent with joy and not sighing as they will cause damage.
My suggestion is to consider matters from all viewpoints.