Tommy Boy Hi Welcome,
First of all if you are a true christian, this issue wouldn't make any possible difference to you, the important thing is that Jesus died as a ransom sacrifice NOT HOW he died.
As far as the JWs go, I personally believe one fine beautiful morning, Ol Judge Rutherford (I think it was He at the time) woke up from a pretty heavy nights drinking and was so hungover he decided he was going to make up a new papal Bull for the congregations.
He decided to make up a story, and see how far he could push it, so he thought and he thought and decided The Stake vs The Cross was a goody. So he went with it.
Soon it was all typed out and ready for print. A Brand New issue of the Watchtower declared that NEW LIGHT had been found that Jesus in fact was not crucified as they had earlier thought NO, that he was in fact Staked! Yep STAKED!
And this was such important new light that from now on anyone claiming to be a true christian and a member of the congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses, found still believing Jesus was crucified, would be in serious trouble. After all this came directly from the source Himself and down to the Fatitful Slave!
Well time went by and people soon started adjusting to this NEW LIGHT! The OL judge went to bed each night mostly sozzled, thinking how funny it was that he managed to convince everyone that Jesus wasn't crucified at all, and thought "Just goes to show how gullible people can be...hehehehe, all indications in history point to Jesus dying on a cross, but I managed to convince these SHEEP otherwise woooohoooo what fun."
"Now what other Papal Bull can I come up with oooh oooh I know......"
Soon a new bright light shone above his head, the rest is History!
here is a link that has discussed this issue before in this Forum, there are many explanations and viewpoints in there.
http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/forum/thread.aspx?id=20279&site=3
So what do you believe? And does it matter?
Edited by - Gizmo on 21 January 2003 8:37:58