The question of quit or control is a massive issue for someone who first comes to realise they have a problem with alcohol.
Every recovering alcoholic that i know would wish that they can control it, but most realise they can't. If you we're to tell a recovering alcoholic that there is this wonder drug that enables you to actively enjoy a controlled social drink i think just about everyone of them would take that drug. But the fact of the matter is that there isn't a drug available that works like that.
I can only speak for myself.
About 3 or 4 years ago i realised i had a problem with drink and drugs(ecstasy and cannabis). Thinking my problem was the drugs (as everyone drinks) i gave them up. This had a massive effect and i felt i was on the correct road. That said i could still go out occasionally and have the odd joint or the odd pill and it was never a problem in that sense.
When i realised my drinking was getting out of control was when i was homeless and my kids needed me (i won't go into why). At the point in my life when my kids needed me most i couldn't do much for them as i was homeless. This had a drastic effect so you know what? I'd control and limit my drinking to the weekend and the odd night. The problem for me is that when i went out on a Friday night i would binge, without even realising it. This would have the effect of having a hangover all weekend. Then came sunday afternoon watching the football with the lads, a few pints didn't hurt did they? Monday i'd have a hangover. Tuesday i'd be okay but someone would phone either Tuesday or Wednesday, again another session. Hangover till Friday. then the process repeated itself.
The thing for me is that i could limit my drinking to maybe just 3 nights a week but the days i wasn't drinking i was hungover anyway.
All i can say is that going through about 2 years of trying to control it, i came to December of last year when because of my job, just about every client i had gave me a bottle of wine for Christmas. I gave up in December trying to control it and thought i'd get drunk over Christmas then phone the AA in the new year.
The new year came and i went to my first AA meeting. I have issues with regards to the spiritual side to it, as some have commented, but walking through those doors on that first night was one of the best things i have ever done in my life. I put it up there with the birth of my kids.
In this time period i have tried controlling it again for about 4 or 5 weeks, with the help of my doctor, but i just didn't enjoy it. The point of a limited controlled social drink is to relax. All i can say for me is that to limit my drinking i can't relax, in fact i don't know whether any alcoholic can.
Now i could mention all the things that drink has done to me, there are some AA meetings where thats all some talk about, i prefer to stay away from those type of meetings, because i have a list as long as my arm as to what drinks done to me but i don't like to dwell on it. There are other meetings where they talk of the positive stuff non drinking has done, those are the ones i go to.
So to finish on a positive note, since i have decided to stop drinking taking each day at a time (there have been a couple of slips, but only slips). My confidence has come back, every time i have a problem i now face it head on. I will stare an issue in the face, whereas beforehand i would drink on it and make it a bigger issue. I now have a great relationship with my kids, we do stuff together. Tonight i walked the dog to the shops with my daughter having a laugh. I picked my son up from school, laughing all the way back to the car. My sense of humour has come back. I have took up scuba diving, something i have wanted to do since i was a kid! I go to the gym. I now even have a car that is fully mot'd, insured and taxed and i never drive it over the limit. I have started earning some decent money, i even have a savings account, something i have never had. I look forward to each day that i am not drinking. My social life is changing away from the drink scene, it takes time. It's these little things to me that makes a difference and guess what, all these little things add up to one big thing. At the forefront of this though is a great relationship with my kids.
Would i like to control my drinking? Yes, i'd love to, but hey i can't. The only drink i can control is not to pick up the first one.
Paul