rjharris-
a Jew is a person who was born one and who comes from that lineage.
Religion does not and cannot change a persons lineage. You try to speak for god about who he thinks is a Jew or not. You can believe whatever you want, but it is only religion. Anybody can change their religion. No-one can change their lineage.
Your statement that Israel today is a murderer and your putting them in the same catagory as Hamas and Isis is both ignorant and insulting.
Religion creates hatred and judgementalism. If it were up to me, all religion would be gone starting with Islam.
Paul's words you quote as to who is a Jew contradict the Hebrew scriptures. He was creating a new religion and his words as well as the rest of the NT holds no weight- it has no authority.
I am amazed I did not see it as a witness, (though my family did), how absurd it is for non-Jews to claim natural Jews are NOT Jews and non-Jews are. I am a Jew by birth, as are all of my blood relatives. My lineage proves who I am, not what some made up religion teaches.