Welcome DocHouse please enjoy your visit . If keep your mind and eyes open on your journey here you, will find an interesting experience ahead of you.
You do know that if you told the Elders that you think alot of what the f&ds says is baloney and added on you would be labled an apostate?
Many are here for that same reason. They agree with you. But like you they did not have anyone they could discuss it with safely and respectfully .
You say respectful debates are rare here. I disagree. Check some more threads out with an open mind. Stifle your automatic reflex to defend or counter argue. Just "listen" and stop to really think about the argument you were going to use. Does it really make sense or was it preprogrammed responses you are repeating from the publications or meetings?
The reason these people here are giving you their time to "respectfully debate" you is because many of them were you. They were right where you are now.
They also can pretty much predict what your responses will be because that is what they would have said. The difference is now they know why the responses are not accurate and what the logical fallacies were that prompted them.
They also know that you have to discover it on your own. They can point the way and give you the benifet of their research, but ultimately it is up to you.
They know you have made the first step by coming here and by admitting to recognise the baloney.
Enjoy the freedom here to explore and question.
Remember respect goes both ways.
BTW I am here because I want to cut the baloney out of my diet. But as an active JW I did not have that option.
Here I do. I can openly question and discuss things without fear of being shunned.
RE the dont feed the troll comment: I think some people are too quick to jump on the troll wagon. I appreciate the posters here that give posters the benifet of the doubt.
You dont know how many trolls have turned into critical thinking posters( aka apostates.)