Dear Friend,
You have opened a can of worms - and I truly wish I knew how to copy your post with those cute little lines that you and Frenchy use. How do you guys do that? (I am quite well written on the lack of my computer literacy.)
However, I did, in fact, write a 4 or 5 page, single spaced letter to the Society about the actions of the elders when they handled my daughter's disfellowshipping. They were wrong - even the Circuit Overseer said so in his subsequent visit to my house.
I did not receive a response from my beloved Society for my "respectful" outpouring of my heart and my anguish. I did recieve a visit from the Circuit Overseer and Presiding Overseer of my congregation - unsolicitated, but nevertheless, ok.
The CO explained that's how the Society did it sometimes - the Society sends the letter to the CO and the CO and PO come see the writer - and I thought ok so we talked. And he did agree that the elders handling my daughter's disfellowshipping were completely ignorant on how to even talk, let alone handle, an incest survivor - especially when one of the men who abused her was a ministerial servant. And you might ask, how do I know this? Because I called the cong. where I raised my daughter and told them and they said they had just received a letter from him own daughter about years of incest and rape at his hands. My daughter was this older girl's little companion.
Three years ago, my husband and I wrote a 33 page letter, plus 100 pages of legal attachments (deeds, bank closing statements, surveys, appraisals, etc.) to the Society, pleading with them to look into an issue that cost us over $100,000 dealing with the body of elders.
The Society replied that they were sending a copy of our letter to the elders in our congregation, and then they would be in a better position to answer our letter. I am quoting as their letter was only two paragraphs long.
We waited approx. nine months then approached our CO, asking him, respectfully, to meet with us about this issue. He called Serv. Dept. for a copy of our long letter and he said: "I was told not to talk to you about this matter, they said they were handling it." It has now been a year and we're still, respectfully (kinda), waiting for a reply.
So, just because you've been an elder for many years, and things weren't handled this way in your congregation - doesn't mean it's that way in all of congregations. Your argument only holds water in your local well. Our water tastes rather poisoned.