Cygnus, just saw your response. Otherwise I would have responded sooner.
You wrote: "But the fact is: accusation of rape or child molestation is perhaps the worst allegation that could be made against somebody, especially if that person is a professed Christian and otherwise seemingly upstanding in conduct and behavior."
I know something that is worse: being the rape or molestation victim. The fact that the elders want to make sure the accusation is true does not take away from the way they handle the victim. They are not qualified...That is my point. This is way over their heads and please tell me, what are the chances that 3 men have the qualifications to deal with any of the following: a crime, an accusation as serious as rape; a victim's feelings; trauma, and on and on.
They should get out of this business immediately; leave it to professionals, social workers, police, therapists. If the Elders handling our case had called annonomously the police or child care workers and said, "We are aware of 4 children who have been sexually abused over a period of years, but we feel by excommunicating the perpetrator this will be enough to stop his reign of terror," do you think the reply would be: "Good plan." I think not.
It's time to stop playing God. Improper handling of rape and molestation cases enables the perpertrator to continue their reign of terror.
You state: "Put yourself in their shoes." My god, man what the hell are you talking about? Put yourselves in the victims' shoes.