Here is Gladden's take on Higher Criticism. Without rancor a comment objective and sensible. You might be interested to know Snoozy the book of Hebrews was also contested as to its inculsion in the canon. Interesting to see how they voted on which books were allowed into the Bible...
( Snoozy )...Interesting indeed. Kind of like the gb, eh?
A great amount of study has been expended
of late on the Scriptures, and the conclusions
reached by this study are of
What is called the Higher Criticism has been
busy scanning these old writings, and trying to
find out all about them. What is the Higher
Criticism ? It is the attempt to learn from the
Scriptures themselves the truth about their ori-
gin. It consists in a careful study of the Ian-
guage of the books, of the manners and customs
referred to in them, of the historical facts men-
tioned by them ; it compares part with part, and
book with book, to discover agreements, if they
exist, and discrepancies, that they may be recon-
ciled.
But much of this criticism has been thoroughly can-
did and reverent, even conservative in its temper
and purpose. It has not been unwilling to look
at the facts ; but it has held toward the Bible a
devout and sympathetic attitude ; it believes it to
contain, as no other book in the world contains,
the message of God to men ; and it has only
sought to learn from the Bible itself how that
message has been conveyed.
It is this conservative criticism whose leadership will be followed
in these studies. No conclusions respecting the
history of these writings will be stated which are
not accepted by conservative scholars. Never-
theless it must be remembered that the results of
conservative scholarship have been very imper-
fectly reported to the laity of the churches.
Many facts about the Bible are now known by
intelligent ministers of which their congregations
do not hear. An anxious and not unnatural feel-
ing has prevailed that the faith of the people in
the Bible would be shaken if the facts were
known. The belief that the truth is the safest
thing in the world, and that the things which
cannot be shaken will remain after it is all told,
has led to the preparation of this volume...pg3-4