Glad you took the time to comment Curtains, an interesting answer to the OP. Lets see where my counter comment deviates from yours.
I have come to believe that most, not all, people reason in the abstract wheather spritual ( I leave all relgion out of it, as religion is doctronial and restricts free flow of thoughts and ideas ) or, from the science point of view. Our abstract thinking sets us on a course of "thinking things" out. We continue to reason with subjective thinking, although anylitical reasoning pops up here and there, as we continue to move along "thinking things" out. Eventualy we reach a conclusion. Therin lies the conundrum, because the conclusion depends on the frame of reference we start with. So, I agree with your statement that our belifes and conclusions are neither completely objective nor subjective.
The wave ( ripple ) effect you bring to the table is interesting. Seems to me that a wave affecting peoples thinking would depend on how far YOU are from the epicenter of the cause. Many people , even those, in the center of the cause let it wash over them without changing their thinking. While some far out on the edge once again start with abstract thinking and subjective reasoning, Therefore it contiues, past and present, changing peoples lives in various ways.
Humanity is in a constant state of flux. Heard on the news this morning that after hard physical work a cold beer did more to slack your thrist and refresh you than a cold glass of water. Several years ago doctors were saying avoid eggs. Now they are saying go ahead eat eggs two, three times a week, there good for you.
On this understanding I agree that atheists and believers are open to these events but will describe them in different ways. ( Curtains ) I agree, in this thread, I said there is no right or wrong answer. What you believe is subjective to your experence of life. You made a comment to that effect yourself. Here we find ourselfs leaning strongly on the subjective, or, objective, depending on our individual thiking.