Was Jesus Schizophrenic?

by StinkyPantz 24 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • jst2laws


    You are speaking of things I'm am unaware of. You say of Stinky:

    You have a mouth on you like no other around here

    Yet she has not attacked you or anyone else as you did her in that remark.

    You say she is an:

    argumentative aethist

    Yet with no debate she apologizes to you and anyone who might be insulted. How is this argumentative? Are you refering to past discussions I have missed? In this perticular discussion Stinky looks like an early heretic attacked by the orthodoxy simply for questioning the accepted dogma. No, I do not think Jesus was Schitzo, but Stinky is not saying he was either.


  • Mystery

    It is an interesting theory. I do believe in Jesus and the Bible. The questions was a theory; not a statement.

    DJ - Instead of brow beating StinkyPantz, simply answer the question or skip to the next thread. Not everyone on this board was offended by the question.

    To answer it; in my opinion, No Jesus wasn't a schizophrenic. Do I have proof? No. It is a theory. Each of us have our own beliefs now. Not "the only way is the JW way."

    Do I feel any different about SP bringing this up? No. She made all of us think about it, even for a split second.

    Actually the title of the thread made me laugh. I don't think he was, but I may be..... I wasn't even going to read it until I read your apology thread. And after reading it I see no reason for you to apologize.

  • Aztec

    *Confused* Where would anyone get the idea that StinkyPantz was rude? Blasphemy? LOL! I don't believe that Jesus even existed myself..hows about that?! God? Same there. I'll believe what I want to believe and you all do the same. You don't like my opinion? Fine by me... :) ~Aztec the agnostic

  • DJ


    Your mixed up. I did not call her argumentative after her apology. I don't think that she would deny being argumentative. She is not stupid so I'm sure that she knows that she argues most of her time here. I have no problem with her beliefs, they are hers but I asked her to be considerate of those who would be offended at her question about Jesus' mental state. Like I said, she is no dummy and I don't think that she wrote that thread without knowing that the mere concept of calling into question the idea that Christ was a head case....wouldn't bother those who trust in Him. You see, maybe you don't understand it but a Christian defends the Christ. Hey, maybe intolerant was harsh for her but she has never shown me anything other than intolerance by means of her constant need to engage Christians is answering her questions and then arguing until she can't find anything else to argue over. She is sarcastic to Christians. Perhaps you need to go through her history. It seems that she lives to argue with Christians. I say it's fine by me to be an aethist but don't purposely ask questions of unsuspecting Christians who are not aware that your reason for the question is only to argue. I am not easily angered by posters and it has been a long time of observance that led me to my conclusion. I was only stating my opinion. I am entilted to it remember? Stink knows in her heart why she posts things that will hurt Christians. Anyone who calls himself a Christian that isn't offended by her would appear to me anyway, to be less than fully devoted. Either you defend Him or you just don't give a crap. Stink, would you like it if I started a thread asking if someone that you love and are devoted to is a schitz? Think about that in all honesty.

  • StinkyPantz


    You accuse me of not letting an argument go? I apologized, what else do you want?

    I am argumentative yes, but not only for atheism.

    I have adamently defended gays: http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/12/48358/1.ashx

    I've defended blacks: http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/6/46069/649888/post.ashx#649888 ; http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/7/50810/1.ashx

    I argue for capital punishment: http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/12/50708/1.ashx

    My questioning of Jesus' validity is nothing personal. Also you asked if I'd be mad if you said that someone I loved had schizophrenia. Maybe, but you've never met Jesus. He lived thousands of years ago!

    Stink knows in her heart why she posts things that will hurt Christians.

    You obviously don't know me.

    Anyway, I'm sorry I hurt you. I've stated that already, now will you just drop it? I'm willing to.

Share this