I'm ashamed to admit that, while I've lived my entire life within about 3 hours of NYC (and now live less than 1 hour away) I've only seen three actual on-Broadway shows in my life: Hair in 1970, Saturday Night Fever, about 3 years ago, and The Graduate last year. The latter was a little disappointing, as I had been looking forward to seeing Kathleen Turner on stage as Mrs. Robinson, but she was on vacation when we went and the role was played by Linda Gray. I would even have been happy to see Lorraine Bracco, who took over the role later on, but no such luck.
I saw the road version of Phantom of the Opera in Boston, and that was simply magnificent.
And, my wife and I are subscribers to the Paper Mill Playhouse here in NJ, so six times a year, we see some very professional, well-done theater, often with major stars. Last year, one of the plays was I'm Not Rappaport, revived at the Paper Mill with Judd Hirsch and Ben Vereen just before it re-opened on Broadway. This season so far, we've seen Miss Saigon, Annie and a play I had never heard of, Blue, starring Leslie Uggams. That last one was much better than I expected it to be; I didn't think it looked that interesting from the pre-advertisement, but I really enjoyed it. Still upcoming for the remainder of the season are Romeo and Bernadette (this coming Saturday), a comedy that is said to combine Shakespeare with the Sopranos, then later in the season, Camelot, and to close the season, Grease.