Just my 2 cents.
I think he should be allowed to stay under the condition he is honest and forthright from now on. I think the humility of an admission post should be rewarded. That being said, its true this is not a Democracy, and Simon has final say. because he has created this environment, we all respect that.
Maybe I feel that way too, because I have alot in common with this guy. Started vehemently defending JW's in order to "prove" my truth to me. Even though the simple actof being on apologetic sites is already a break with the religion, it was my first step. People didn't always like me, and I was not 100% honest. In the end however, here I am. Hopefully a posative member of the community. Although I still am maybe defensive of "some things" regarding the religion of my youth, I also try to communicate and cooperate in a meaningful way.
The purpose of the board is to WELCOME dissent. This is the way he dissented. Now he is on a humble path of acknowledgement.
Like I said. Reminds me of me. I am still "in" as well. So just my thoughts. I defer to the group. But I don't like disfellowshipping....even from this place.
Ethos....my e mail to PM me on is jeffmunson1 "at" gmail.com
It is not my real name. Hit me up. We have alot in common and if nothing else, we can talk a bit.