Taking the bull by the horns

by fullofdoubtnow 24 Replies latest jw friends

  • fullofdoubtnow
    fullofdoubtnow

    My friend Marion, who has been trying to fade, decided on a change of tactics, and sent the following letter to the elders last weekend:

    Body of Elders

    Xxxxxxx Congregation of Jehovahs Witnesses

    Dear Brothers

    As you know, I have not been attending meetings during the last few months, a matter over which you have all expressed some concern.

    I thankyou all for the attention you have paid me during this time, and express my apologies for my seeming lack of appreciation for your efforts. Be assured, brothers, your efforts have not gone unappreciated, I have simply not felt like talking about the things that have been troubling me during these last few months.

    I would like to say at this point that my problems do not stem from anything that you yourselves have done individually, they are from within. After being associated with Jehovahs Witnesses for my entire life, I find myself beginning to doubt some of the teachings I have held to for so long. The Bible tells us to “ make sure of all things.. ” (Thess ), and of late I have been trying to do that, by means of deep personal Bible study and prayer. Again, we are admonished to “ keep on testing that we are in the faith.. ” (2Cor 13:5), and, whilst a few years ago I was absolutely certain that I was, now I am no longer sure.

    I know that everyone goes through periods of doubt like the one I am experiencing now, and you will advise me that the meetings are the best place to resolve things, but I feel I need time to myself at this point, and would hope that you will respect my wishes, at least in the immediate future. I do not wish at present to discuss the thoughts that I have been having, so whilst I again emphasise how much I appreciate your concern at my absence, please respect my desire for privacy . When I am ready, I promise you that I will be in touch. Until then, whilst I will of course welcome anyone who calls on me in friendship, as I always have, I would prefer to be left alone.

    Your Sister

    When she sent this letter, which Trev and I both knew about (he typed it), we all felt that there would be one of two possible outcomes - they would respect her wish to be left alone, thus buying herself some time so to speak, or they would contact her immediately after the elders meeting, which was last night. Well, it seems they took the 2nd option, as she had a message on her answering machine this morning from the po thanking her for her letter, and telling her that the elders would like to speak to her to address the nature of the doubts she mentioned in her letter.

    She hasn't contacted him yet, and we have advised her not to, but I think they will now redouble their efforts to see her, and when they do they are going to ask some awkward questions. Trev told her as he was typing it that this letter could well lead to a jc eventually, but she thinks that may have been on the cards anyway, as her jw son visited her last week and spotted the copy of Crisis of Conscience I lent her. She admitted to having read it, and he probably put 2 & 2 together, with her missing all the meetings lately. He didn't say he would report it, but he wants to be an ms so it's likely he will mention it to the elders.

    She will be visiting us later, so I will be able to update everyone if there have been any further developements, but it is book study night, so maybe she won't be bothered again today. She knows there will be some pretty leading questions if the elders do corner her, and she has decided to answer them honestly rather than try to be evasive. She would still kind of prefer to fade, but doesn't think the elders will allow it, hence the letter. Her attitude is that she doesn't really want to be df'd, but if it happens, then so be it. Whatever comes of all this, she isn't going back to the meetings.

    Please keep her in your thoughts, and I will keep you updated as and when there are any developements.

    Linda

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    Let the games begin...

    Personally I had never heard of Crisis of Conscience, before I read about it here, and decided not to buy anything like that before I DA'ed. Do you think we can sometimes be a little nervous about things, giving people more credit than we ought?

  • Bumble Bee
    Bumble Bee
    I know that everyone goes through periods of doubt like the one I am experiencing now, and you will advise me that the meetings are the best place to resolve things, but I feel I need time to myself at this point, and would hope that you will respect my wishes, at least in the immediate future. I do not wish at present to discuss the thoughts that I have been having, so whilst I again emphasise how much I appreciate your concern at my absence, please respect my desire for privacy

    HHmmm, wonder which part of "please respect my privacy" they didn't get?

    BB

  • fullofdoubtnow
    fullofdoubtnow
    Do you think we can sometimes be a little nervous about things, giving people more credit than we ought?

    You may be right LT, but her son was pretty shocked when he saw COC in his mothers' house, very careless of her to leave it lying around, but it was a surprise visit. He might not have ratted her out, but he is ambitious so....

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    BB:

    HHmmm, wonder which part of "please respect my privacy" they didn't get?

    "Please"?

  • Crumpet
    Crumpet

    Also whilst the title may be unfamiliar to most JWs the author's name is bound to trigger some recognition for anyone who has been in the borg long enough to know the various presidents and GB members.

  • garybuss
    garybuss

    From my experience, never treat the Witnesses like they are ethical people, and they will treat you reasonably, because they aren't . . . and they won't.

  • freetosee
    freetosee

    The letter is very good, had her son not found COC the elders might have respected it. If her son told them about it they will be after her. He is reaching out for privileges and wants to save his mother. She admitted to him that she has been reading it. The books front page says “by a former member of the governing body”. That’s High Alert for the elders. I think a jc can be expected, since they want to meet with her after her request to be left alone. fts

  • fullofdoubtnow
    fullofdoubtnow
    From my experience, never treat the Witnesses like they are ethical people, and they will treat you reasonably, because they aren't . . . and they won't.

    I learned how "reasonable" the elders could be myself, Gary, and it's the same body who are dealing with my friend, so I guess she knew what to expect, whatever she was hoping for by sending them the letter. She isn't going to make it easy for them, that's for sure, but I suppose they'll catch up with her one day. She's been a stalwart in that congregation for so long that I just don't believe they will let her fade, no matter how hard she tries to do it.

  • Bumble Bee
    Bumble Bee
    very careless of her to leave it lying around,

    I have a wee bit of a problem with this statement. It's her house. I have had similar things like this happen in the past, and it wouldn't matter where the book was, JW's seem to be able to sniff things out that you don't want them to see.

    Once, during a shepherding visit I was surprised when one of the brothers mentioned a book I had in the book case. This was a slim book, he would have had to really squinted to see the title. How he managed to see it I still can't figure out as the case was in a nook, and my chair was beside it, blocking most of the view. The book was about living with back pain (was having back problems at the time). While there was nothing wrong with that book, the fact that he had to actively look for the book is what shocked me. What else was he snooping around and looking for? Did he open all the cupboards in the bathroom while he was in there? Gawd I hate people snooping around in my stuff !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    I have a problem with my mother when she comes over as well. I had some Christian books and CD's that were not out in the open, and there was no reason for her to be where they were. I hate people snooping in my stuf !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Did I mention how much I hate people snooping around in my stuff ?????!!!!!!!! lol

    BB

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit