Watchtower claim to be a small business to avoid Privacy Act. What do I do?

by jwfacts 22 Replies latest watchtower scandals

  • jwfacts
    jwfacts

    I sent a letter to the WTS requesting my personal records under the Privacy Act. They refused so I went to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner. I just received a letter back saying they can not investigate it as the Watchtower is a small business. The Australian Privacy Act claims that a business over annual turnover of more than $3 million dollars needs to provide people with their personal information on request.

    Here is an excerpt of the letter from the Compliance Officer:

    PRIVACY COMPLAINT AGAINST THE WATCHTOWER BIBLE & TRACT SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA

    "... I wrote to a representative of Watchtower as part of my preliminary enquires into you case under section 42 to the Act. Watchtower responded by forwarding a signed Statutory Declaration to this OFfice which advised that it does not provide a health service, does not trade in personal information and is not a subsidiary of a company that is covered by the Act.

    For this reason, Watchtower is a small business operator and is an exempt organisation as defined under section 6C of the Act. The Commissioner is unable to investigate the actions of Watchtower.

    As a result I have decideed under section 41(1)(a) of the Act to cease investigation of this matter on the grounds that the compliant that you raise falls outside the areas for which the Commissioner has jurisdiction.

    If you consider that the process by which this Office made its decision was unfair you can submit an application to apeal the decision to the Federal Court ..."

    The Watchtower receives well in excess of $3 million, does this count as a turnover of more than $3 million in Australia. The term is 'subsidiary of such a company', so even with a complex legal structure I imagine that they still should be looking at the combined turnover of the group.

    I am wondering if it is still worth pursuing.

  • Honesty
    Honesty

    bttt

  • sf
    sf
    If you consider that the process by which this Office made its decision was unfair you can submit an application to apeal the decision to the Federal Court ..."

    Do you have an attorney yourself?

    I'd appeal to the Federal court, if it were me.

    sKally

  • jwfacts
    jwfacts

    I am totally broke just at the moment, but this may change over the next six months. I am wondering if I could represent myself, but need to research if I would be up for any WTS costs if I lost the case.

  • jwfacts
    jwfacts

    I wonder if the WTS is attempting to claim that Turnover does not include donations?

  • LDH
    LDH

    Let me think about this.

    One thing I would do in the meantime, is send a certified mail request for the legal definition of a small business. It looks like, if you don't fit the other categories, they assume you are a small business.

    We have to define the term first.

    Here in California we have the Department of Corporations that would oversee something like that, but I have no idea about down under.

    Lisa

  • SickofLies
    SickofLies

    Have you thought about putting together and article about what you were asking for, how you tried to get, why you were turned down, how the government ignored you, etc and sending it to the press? Local papers usually love that sorta story. Worth a shot.

  • Quotes
    Quotes

    "...you can submit an application to appeal the decision..."

    BINGO.

    I take it for granted that WTS Australia has annual revenues in excess of AUD$3M. Now, they might claim that they give it all away (to WTS Crooklyn) and have nothing left. Well, that defies the "not part of another organization" angle they are running.

    Does your local TV station have one of those "Action reporter on your side, helping you fight back" reporters? I'll bet you could get one interested.

    BTW, now that Canada has a Privacy Act, has anyone tried this here in Canuckistan?

    ~Q

  • jwfacts
    jwfacts

    I just was directed to a thread that shows the WTS had $17 million turnover in 2002. I went to the ASIC website which shows that the WTS lodges a financial report with ASIC yearly, but I can not work out how to get it. You can purchase a summary of the company details, but I cant see if the entire financial report can be downloaded. Does anyone have experience with this.

    ASIC Watchtower details is at http://www.search.asic.gov.au/cgi-bin/gns030c?acn=002_861_225&juris=9&hdtext=ACN&srchsrc=1

  • rebel8
    rebel8

    I agree it’d be best to hire an attorney, but if that’s not possible you may be able to have success anyway. I wonder if it would be worthwhile to write a letter stating the WT's affirmation was false and requesting they reopen the investigation? If they would do that, it would save you from going to court. Link to section 6 defining covered entities 6C Organisations What is an organisation?
    (1) In this Act: organisation means:
    (a) an individual; or
    (b) a body corporate; or
    (c) a partnership; or
    (d) any other unincorporated association; or
    (e) a trust;

    that is not a small business operator, a registered political party, an agency, a State or Territory authority or a prescribed instrumentality of a State or Territory. Note: Regulations may prescribe an instrumentality by reference to one or more classes of instrumentality. See subsection 46(2) of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901.

    Example: Regulations may prescribe an instrumentality of a State or Territory that is an incorporated company, society or association and therefore not a State or Territory authority.

    6D Small business and small business operators What is a small business?

    (1) A business is a small business at a time (the test time) in a financial year (the current year) if its annual turnover for the previous financial year is $3,000,000 or less.

    Test for new business

    (2) However, if there was no time in the previous financial year when the business was carried on, the business is a small business at the test time only if its annual turnover for the current year is $3,000,000 or less.

    What is a small business operator?

    (3) A small business operator is an individual, body corporate, partnership, unincorporated association or trust that:

    (a) carries on one or more small businesses; and

    (b) does not carry on a business that is not a small business.

    Entities that are not small business operators

    (4) However, an individual, body corporate, partnership, unincorporated association or trust is not a small business operator if he, she or it:

    (a) carries on a business that has had an annual turnover of more than $3,000,000 for a financial year that has ended after the later of the following:

    (i) the time he, she or it started to carry on the business;

    (ii) the commencement of this section; or

    (b) provides a health service to another individual and holds any health information except in an employee record; or

    (c) discloses personal information about another individual to anyone else for a benefit, service or advantage; or

    (d) provides a benefit, service or advantage to collect personal information about another individual from anyone else; or

    (e) is a contracted service provider for a Commonwealth contract (whether or not a party to the contract).

    So it seems you must address all items from 4a-4e. If I were you, I’d try responding by pasting section 4a-4e above and giving bullet points why it meets the definition of covered entities, under each lettered item. I will help compose a response if you want, but it would go something like this (after introductory paragraph):

    "The (official name of your privacy law, section blah blah blah), says:

    'However, an individual, body corporate, partnership, unincorporated association or trust is not a small business operator if he, she or it:

    (a) carries on a business that has had an annual turnover of more than $3,000,000 for a financial year that has ended after the later of the following:

    (i) the time he, she or it started to carry on the business;

    (ii) the commencement of this section; or…'

    The WTS has an annual turnover of $_______, as evidenced by ______. Thus, the WTS does not qualify as a small business under this section.

    The privacy act also defines exempt organizations as those who '(b) provides a health service to another individual and holds any health information except in an employee record; or…'

    The WTS provides health services to its volunteers at branch headquarters…"

    …And so on, addressing each of the points in the small business definition and listing reasons the WTS does meet the definition.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit