Gretchen,
I feel just like you. For the first 12 years of my life I was not JW. Noone taught me the concept of sacrifice but I often found myself "offering" something to God...little trinkets. I still wonder about where I got that idea and why it felt so right to me. I also had a collection of fairy ornaments and I would sit under our oak tree talking to the fairies (I think I actually did...but who knows?). Since being little I could sense people's illnesses and see auras.
I used to write poetry and fairly recently I got some of it out for a friend to read. She commented straight away on how "pagan" they were! I hadn't even thought of it, but when I re-read them she was right.
Sirona