Breaking News: Big Trouble with the Watchtower (page 3)

Farkel

Sigh. If only JWs would as be skeptical about their own religion as we all are about what is said about their own religion.

Farkel, Dream On CLASS

OUTLAW

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm.......

We get lots of Storys..

Until theres Proof..

It`s just a Story..

AE:

Don`t fall off your Soap Box..

................................OUTLAW

AE's typical bullshit aside (yes, go f*&% yourself, AE), it would be nice to have more info on this, espeically since it's coming from a new poster. THe part that makes me especially suspicious is the Oprah invitation and major book deal. Also, this is not anywhere near "the worst story" in connection with how Watchtower treats people.

quietlyleaving

thanks for posting this bethel elder - it sounds very believable to me

edit: very skeptical about a book deal or Orprah materializing though. The story itself sounds very characteristic of WTS shenannigans

daniel-p

Sigh. If only JWs would as be skeptical about their own religion as we all are about what is said about their own religion.

Farkel, don't lament our reasoning ability--we've simply regained a healthy sense of suspicion... something the Jdubs don't have. We do have aguy's name, though. I wonder if there would be a way to verify if this Mel Smith was, indeed a Bethelite.

Bethelite Elder

Why don't you just call him? Google

The Almighty Homer

I guess trying to take money away from god's kingdom is a great sin.

Its one of the ten isn't ?

leavingwt

The chairman/ PO sent him a certified letter with a blank sheet of paper inside; to supposedly invite him to a Judicial Committee.

Why not just send an actual letter, requesting his presence at a JC?

They don't need a legitimate reason to DF someone who does attend a JC. So, this particular detail of the story is strange, IMHO.

daniel-p

Since you would like to know so bad, why don't you just call him. Are you suspicious of using Google too? or would you just like to talk jibberish and bouces around in doubt. It's not that hard to find anyone nowadays fare fellows.

No need to be a dick, man. Not all of us are immediately suspicious, but just want more info. I did indeed google his name and came up with nothing. Do you have his contact info? Which complex did he serve at? How did you hear of his situation?

These are not questions to discredit you, just to elaborate the story a little.

Billy the Ex-Bethelite

Bethelite Elder,

Melchester Smith? Was he a Walkill Watchman guy about 5 years ago?

I would love to see one of these cases blow open on WT. If I would have had just a little recorder for some of the conversations I witnessed, I could become a millionaire! Unfortunately, WT lawyers are sharp at burying the sh!t.

B the X

Breaking News: Big Trouble with the Watchtower

Share this