ThiChi I wanted to add that in the article that I read (Maybe Wall Street Journal) the man shot also had a knife (sheathed) under his shirt. And (like you) I also read that he was trying to get the officers gun. He was shot by the other officer. As I read it, the argument is that if you say to the cops that you don't want to talk then they HAVE to leave you alone. Pleading the 5th means that you have the right to stay silent. I have not read where that means that the cops have to be silent. And the argument was over if medical care was being withheld and the anwer is again no. The cops left when told so by medical staff at the hospital. If this guy was minding his own business and got pissed at the cops and got paralized and blinded for being in the wrong place that is just wrong.Was his 5th (civil rights) violated we will see. But in my ordinary uneducated American citizen opinion, nope.
Here is a tip fighting with the cops is always a bad idea. Going for their gun that is suicide.
I guess some people will have to go back to the drawing board to sling mud at President Bush this one is not going to stick. I do not think that we are in a police state nor do I think that is what his intent is.