Posts by Saintbertholdt

21

What Just Showed Up in My Facebook Feed

by Dissonant15 in

gross!!!

i think i'm going to be sick.

time to unfollow & block more people... .

Saintbertholdt

23

Elusive happiness teaches a hidden truth!

by iconoclastic in

many seek happiness externally and many a time assign others the possession of their happiness.

when they derive a sort of happiness from external sources, they dont feel satisfied, hence jump to the next and then to the next .... in contrast, jesus said gods kingdom (or real happiness) is within (entos) you.

this cannot be misinterpreted as jesus being the king of the kingdom was amidst them as jws do.

Saintbertholdt

Why are the Brahma Kumari's targeting this site?

I wonder that myself. If I was in Brahma Kumaris I would target people on new age forums because they would eat up iconoclastics posts. Targeting ex-JW members is almost like Jehovah's Witnesses trying to target fundamentalist Muslims. True its an interesting challenge but it can't be too rewarding.

My own response is thus: "So what you're trying to sell to me is that the 130 Year old bourbon whiskey which I had to give up because it was bad for my health, I now have to exchange for your one year old bathtub gin?".

13

Blondie's Comments You Will Not Hear at the 09-20-2015 WT Study (LOYALTY)

by blondie in

blondies highlights from the 09-20-2015 wt study (july 15, 2015), pages (22-26) .

excellent general website: www.jwfacts.com .

bible translations www.biblegateway.com/cgi-bin/bible .

Saintbertholdt

"Take, for example, Mirjeta from a region of the former Yugoslavia. She was raised to hate Serbians. On learning that Jehovah is impartial and that Satan is responsible for inciting ethnic problems, she strove to rid herself of nationalistic sentiments...I try to imitate Jehovah’s loving personality."

Mirjeta, thank goodness you listen to the Watchtowers point of view because if you really imitated Jehovah, well...

1 Samual 14:47-48 "After Saul had assumed rule over Israel, he fought against their enemies on every side: Moab, the Ammonites, Edom, the kings of Zobah, and the Philistines. Wherever he turned, he inflicted punishment on them. He fought valiantly and defeated the Amalekites, delivering Israel from the hands of those who had plundered them."

Whats that Mirjeta? From the above we can see that Jehovah only had pagan non Jewish ethnicities slaughtered because they actually innitiated the strife? Bravo and sharply spotted. Mirjeta that must be a load off your mind, phew! Jehovah would never start an ethnic cleansing war now would he?

Deuteronomy 20:16–18 “Only in the cities of these peoples that the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance, you shall not leave alive anything that breathes. But you shall utterly destroy them: the Hittite and the Amorite, the Canaanite and the Perizzite, the Hivite and the Jebusite, as the Lord your God has commanded you, so that they may not teach you to do according to all their detestable things which they have done for their gods, so that you would sin against the Lord your God”

Oh I see Mirjeta, Jehovah destroyed them because of the "detestable things which they [did] for their gods"...which Israel then proceeded to do under the Lords command, which made it all ok.

Seeing as Serbs are mostly Serbian Orthodox and obviously not Jehovah's Witnesses, Mirjeta you should actually be fine when they are slaughtered in ethnic violence. No? Oh its because Jehovah did not command a slaughter of any nation today. But when Armageddon comes those Serbs will shit their pants when God murders them himself, right?

In conclusion I would like to say that I have to now go and take some serious meds because I'm reasoning with an imaginary Croat quoted in a cult magazine who have twisted a desert deity's bloodthirst into wine and roses.

AND THAT'S WHY I CAN'T READ WATCHTOWER ARTICLES!!!

28

Where did they understood the anointed ones would be before the "great crowd" "revelation"?

by paradisebeauty in

this is a question on old doctrine of jw's.

before they came up with the "great crowd" "revelation", where did they preached that the anointed ones will be?

because if they preached it will be in heaven, how did they understood that the prophecies about the earth will be fulfilled?

Saintbertholdt

Which is more confusing, the overlapping generation doctrine or Russell's chart of the ages?

28

Where did they understood the anointed ones would be before the "great crowd" "revelation"?

by paradisebeauty in

this is a question on old doctrine of jw's.

before they came up with the "great crowd" "revelation", where did they preached that the anointed ones will be?

because if they preached it will be in heaven, how did they understood that the prophecies about the earth will be fulfilled?

Saintbertholdt

Ok this is the best I can understand it so far:

Russell:

2 X heavenly classes

1 X Jewish earthly class + proselytes (Pre-pentecostal until present day)

1 X Christian earthly class (non-Bible Students or non-progressors)

Rutherford Bible Student era:

2 X heavenly classes

1 X Jewish earthly class + proselytes (Pre-pentecostal until present day)

1 X Christian earthly class (non-Bible Students or non-progressors) - unsure? Probably not. Post Russell and first World War the organization increasingly became sectarian and Rutherford anti-ecumenical. This sentiment had already germinated with Russell after the separation with his wife.

Rutherford Jehovah's Witness era:

1 X Heavenly class

1 X Earthly class

0 X Jewish earthly class

28

Where did they understood the anointed ones would be before the "great crowd" "revelation"?

by paradisebeauty in

this is a question on old doctrine of jw's.

before they came up with the "great crowd" "revelation", where did they preached that the anointed ones will be?

because if they preached it will be in heaven, how did they understood that the prophecies about the earth will be fulfilled?

Saintbertholdt

Aw crap I don't know any more... This is from Divine Plan of the Ages:

Both the n and m classes are on the spirit-begotten plane, M. These two classes have existed together throughout the Gospel age; both covenanted with God to become living sacrifices; both were "accepted in the beloved" and begotten by the Spirit as "new creatures." The difference between them is this: n represents those who are fulfilling their covenant and are dead with Christ to earthly will, aims and ambitions, whilem represents the larger company of the spirit-begotten children who have covenanted, but who, alas! shrink back from the performance of their covenant. The n class consists of the overcomers who will be the Bride of Christ, who will sit with the Lord in his throne in glory--plane K. This is the "little flock" to whom it is the Father's good pleasure to give the Kingdom. (Luke 12:32) Those of the m class shrink from the death of the human will, but God still loves them, and therefore will bring them by the way of adversity and trouble to plane L, the perfect spiritual plane. But they will have lost the right to plane K, the throne of glory, because they were not overcomers. If we prize our Father's love, if we desire our Lord's approval, if we aspire to be members of his body, his Bride, and to sit in his throne, we must fulfil our covenant of sacrifice faithfully and willingly.The majority of the nominal Church is represented by section p. Notice that they are not on plane M, but on plane N. They are justified but not sanctified. They are not fully consecrated to God, and not begotten, therefore, as spirit beings. They are higher than the world, however, because they accept of Jesus as their ransom from sin; but they have not accepted the high-calling of this age to become part of the spiritual family of God. If they continue in faith and fully submit to the righteous laws of Christ's Kingdom, in the Times of Restitution, they will finally attain the likeness of the perfect earthly man, Adam. They will completely recoverall that was lost through him. They will attain the same human perfection, mental, moral and physical, andwill again be in the image of God, as Adam was; for to all this they were redeemed. And their position of justification, plane N, as those who have heard and believed in the salvation through Christ, is a special blessing which they by faith enjoy sooner than the general world (for all shall be brought to an accurate knowledge of the Truth, in the Millennial age). These, however, will have had the advantage of an earlier start and some progress in the right direction. But class p fails to improve the real benefit of this faith justificationin the present time. It is granted now for the special purpose of enabling some to make the acceptable sacrifice, and to become the n class as members of "the body of Christ." Those of class p receive the favor of God [justification] "in vain" (2 Cor. 6:1): they fail to use it to go on and present themselves acceptable sacrifices, during this time in which sacrifices are acceptable to God. Those of this class, though not "saints," not members of the consecrated "body," are called "brethren" by the Apostle. (Rom. 12:1) In the same sense the entire race, when restored, will forever be brethren of the Christ, and the children of God, though of adifferent nature. God is the Father of all in harmony with him, on every plane and of every nature.

28

Where did they understood the anointed ones would be before the "great crowd" "revelation"?

by paradisebeauty in

this is a question on old doctrine of jw's.

before they came up with the "great crowd" "revelation", where did they preached that the anointed ones will be?

because if they preached it will be in heaven, how did they understood that the prophecies about the earth will be fulfilled?

Saintbertholdt

And the faithful oness on old time to live on earth as princess. Proncess lover who?

Post Armageddon Jews, pre-Pentecostal Israelites and proselytes.

28

Where did they understood the anointed ones would be before the "great crowd" "revelation"?

by paradisebeauty in

this is a question on old doctrine of jw's.

before they came up with the "great crowd" "revelation", where did they preached that the anointed ones will be?

because if they preached it will be in heaven, how did they understood that the prophecies about the earth will be fulfilled?

Saintbertholdt

Rutherford taught multiple classes but I'm not sure about Russell, the book shown above is from Rutherford, is it not Saint?

Yeah its from Millions now living will never die.
I know Russell believed and preached consolation for the Jews. And he also believed in two heavenly classes.

What he believed about the pre-pentecostal earthly resurrection I'm unsure of. He certainly didn't predict 1925, as that was all Rutherford :)

28

Where did they understood the anointed ones would be before the "great crowd" "revelation"?

by paradisebeauty in

this is a question on old doctrine of jw's.

before they came up with the "great crowd" "revelation", where did they preached that the anointed ones will be?

because if they preached it will be in heaven, how did they understood that the prophecies about the earth will be fulfilled?

Saintbertholdt

So in short, there were two heavenly classes which only began after Pentecost.

Everyone before that event would get an earthly resurrection.

The Jews would also be restored to Palestine.

So later Rutherford just amalgamated the second heavenly class with the pre-Pentecost earthly class and dropped the consolation for the Jews.

28

Where did they understood the anointed ones would be before the "great crowd" "revelation"?

by paradisebeauty in

this is a question on old doctrine of jw's.

before they came up with the "great crowd" "revelation", where did they preached that the anointed ones will be?

because if they preached it will be in heaven, how did they understood that the prophecies about the earth will be fulfilled?