Welcome RF
You truly are a "thinking" young man. I admire your quest in doing research!
One of the things you stated was "the lack of love" and how that is how we are suppose to be identified as Jehovah's people, being a JW. That was one of the reasons that finally woke me up. I have moved around a lot in the USA and found that there was NOT a brotherly love by the horrible things said, especially the elders. With my recent moves, all the congregation cared about was my PUBLISHER CARD....NOT ME.
Seeing the last 10 minutes of the May 2002 Dateline that exposed the pedophile problem in the WTBS was my defining moment. I had been a very zealous JW, raised in the religion and raised both my adult sons. It was as Dr. Phil said: "a defining moment in my life". How could I go from door to door saying we are a "clean organization" when we are no better then the Catholics they put down constantly (because of their pedophile problem) ? I went in the door to door one more time. Sat in a car with gossiping elder's wife. That was my last time....early 2003.
Keep posting and reading. Rely on your "gut" feelings, they are there for a reason.
Codeblue