The Time Travel Tale of John Titor -- Brilliant Internet Hoax?

by Country Girl 22 Replies latest jw friends

  • Sirius Dogma
    Sirius Dogma

    From my limited understanding of string theory, there is no way to tell whether or not he was a hoax or was totally legitimate. If he did travel back in time and start saying these things he would have to travel to an alternate and parrelel universe, not his own. In his own universe no such thing happened so going back would create a paradox and that can't happen as I understand it, it would be another universe. Not only that, but the universe he returned to would not be his own. But what the hell do we know. And from what I remeber, he said some things were different, so he likely was never from our universe in the first place. At worst it is a great theoretical story with mostly sound theorys behind it, very hard to disprove what he says.

    Here is a better explanation:

    http://science.howstuffworks.com/time-travel6.htm

    Problems with Time Travel If we are ever able to develop a workable theory for time travel, we would open up the ability to create very complicated problems called paradoxes. A paradox is defined as something that contradicts itself. Here are two common examples:
    • Let's say, for the sake of argument, that you could travel back to a time before you were born. The mere fact that you could exist in a time before you were born creates a paradox. If you were born in 1960, how could you exist in 1955?

    • Possibly the most famous paradox is the grandfather paradox. What would happen if a time traveler went back and killed one of his or her ancestors before the traveler was born? If the person killed his or her grandfather, then how could that person be alive to go back and kill his or her grandfather? If we could change the past, it would create an infinite number of paradoxes.
    Another theory regarding time travel brings up the idea of parallel universes, or alternative histories. Let's say that you do travel back to meet your grandfather when he was a boy. In the theory of parallel universes, you may have traveled to another universe, one that is similar to ours, but has a different succession of events. For instance, if you were to travel back in time and kill one of your ancestors, you've only killed that person in one universe, which is no longer the universe that you exist in. And if you then try to travel back to your own time, you may end up in another parallel universe and never be able to get back to the universe you started in.

    The idea here is that every action causes the creation of a new universe, and that there are an infinite number of universes that exist. When you killed your ancestor, you created a new universe, a universe that was identical to your own up until the time you changed the original succession of events.

  • berten
  • Abaddon
    Abaddon

    I've always viewed the idea that every possible choice of action causes a 'split' and the creation of a parrallel universe for each possible choice to be utter rubbish as it violates the law of conservation of energy.

    Travelling forwards is EASY; just move very fast.

    Travelling backwards is probably impossible unless one where to create constructs like a 1,000km cylinder and spin it around its middle at near the speed of light and creating such a distortion in space time that time becomes a dimension you move in.

    Assuming you had a magic box that would prevent you being smeared into a atom thin layer by the G-forces of such a machine...

    But what would happen if you went and shot your grandfather before he had your dad?

    Either the bullet would 'miss', as your grandfather couldn't have died, as you are there... or the bullet hits and you see gramps croak, but then how did you come to be?... or the bullet hits and you cease to have ever been, but then you wouldn't have killed gramps so you would have existed... you can;t say 'oh he's dead in one time-line and alive in another' as where did the energy for another universe come from?

    Who was it who said time travel is probably impossible because it would be silly?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit