Marc O'Donell's statement: Lloyd and the conflict of Interest

by Diogenesister 48 Replies latest watchtower scandals

  • Diogenesister
    Diogenesister

    As expected from a man who prioritizes the most vulnerable members of our community, Marc has made a sober statement that explains why there's a deep conflict of interest between Lloyds recent behaviour and the work they do at JW Watch. You can read it here:

    https://mobile.twitter.com/Mark_J_ODonnell/status/1492609052651761668

    Public Statement of Mark O’Donnell

    It has come to my attention that on Monday, January 30th, 2022, a Reddit statement by resigned JW Watch operations director Kim Silvio was posted concerning the activities and conduct of JW Watch / JW Survey founder, Lloyd Evans.

    Following that statement, a monetized video was released by Lloyd Evans in which he addressed some of the claims made by Ms. Silvio, who described a private conversation she had with Mr. Evans and one additional person. The Livestream video was replete with expletives and references to alleged sexual contact with prostitutes.

    Evans declared in strong language that his infidelities were not the business of his patrons or the public, stating that how he used donated and other funds is beyond scrutiny.

    I strongly denounce the use of any finances for purposes that create a notable conflict of interest for any reporter covering the sensitive topic of child sexual abuse.

    In my opinion, the links between sex work and the grooming of children, child abuse, violent crime, drugs, and other unlawful activities call into question the credibility of anyone reporting on the subject of child abuse. While it is not my business to judge the personal lives of other reporters, I must take on board the feelings and sensitivities of the general public, including those affected by these activities.

    As a reporter and consultant for child sexual abuse cases in the United States and worldwide, I am obligated to adhere to a reasonable code of conduct that mirrors the gravity and substance of this subject matter. I am also sensitive to the feelings of survivors of abuse who trust my integrity and work. Many of those survivors have conservative values and ethics, and I respect their positions.

    Most news organizations have a code of ethics for reporting and for the conduct of journalists themselves.

    For example, National Public Radio (NPR) recognizes the importance of giving weight to the scruples of its patrons by reminding the public that perception does influence credibility, and that reporters have limitations.

    “To secure the public's trust, we must make it clear that our primary allegiance is to the public. Any personal or professional interests that conflict with that allegiance, whether in appearance or in reality, risk compromising our credibility”
    “We enjoy the right to robust personal lives, yet we accept some unique professional obligations and limitations. Because our words and actions can damage the public's opinion of NPR, we comport ourselves in ways that honor our professional impartiality.” - NPR

    As a result of Mr. Evans’statements, I have resigned from affiliation with Lloyd Evans and JW Watch, effective February 1st, 2022. I will always be thankful for the information I have shared on Lloyd’s website and channel, and I know that those who follow my work respect the long hours and resources I have personally devoted to this endeavor. My work remains unchanged.

    A few facts for clarification:

    ● Neither myself nor my wife Kimberly O’Donnell had any knowledge of these issues until January 30th, when this was made public by Ms. Kim Silvio.

    ● Ms. Silvio released information ahead of her statement to persons not associated with JW Watch, and without the knowledge or consent of Lloyd Evans or his wife.

    ● Ms. Evans had no knowledge or advance notice of the public statement of Ms. Kim Silvio.

    ● I was not funded or employed by Mr. Evans, JW Survey, or JW Watch. My work has been supported by my own personal savings.

    ● Aside from my resignation, I have had no personal communication with Lloyd Evans for several months, and I have received no apology related to his conduct and its impact on those connected with JW Watch or the general public.

    ● I have had absolutely no contact with Kim Silvio or “producer Bob” in any matters related to this issue, either directly or indirectly.

    ● Certain additional allegations against Mr. Evans have surfaced since January 30th that are false and uncorroborated, and have caused great distress to Mr. Evans’ immediate family. I condemn any claims that were made with malicious or slanderous intent and without substantiation.

    References:

    https://www.npr.org/about-npr/688413430/impartiality#impartialityinourpersonallives

    https://www.npr.org/ethics

    Links and articles related to child abuse and prostitution:

    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0145213481900508

    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2254224/

    https://www.irishtimes.com/news/half-of-prostitutes-abused-as-children-1.492031

    https://pcar.org/sites/default/files/pages-pdf/the_intersection_between_prostitution_and_sexual_violence.pdf

    https://www.kidsinthehouse.com/teenager/parenting-teens/at-risk/from-sexual-violation-to-child-prostitution

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/23714392

  • pistolpete
    pistolpete

    This will cut another big percentage of his loyal zealots from staying on as Patrons.

    Or maybe they are of the same type like those that are willing to die for refusing a blood transfusion because listening to 8 old dudes and the good they do "Trumps" their bad conduct and lies.

  • Biahi
    Biahi

    Mark O’Donnell is a very honorable person. I would be proud to have him as a friend. While I agree that what happened with Lloyd was a private matter between him and his wife, let’s face it, a married man visiting prostitutes is sleazy. His credibility is now called into question due to no one knowing the ages of these prostitutes. I pray for his wife and family.

  • Diogenesister
    Diogenesister

    I think it says a lot that following radio silence from Mark on Twitter, Lloyd unfollowed him. He is so narcissistic he cannot understand that he's put mark in an impossible position and that Marks priority has to be the women & kids he advocates for.

    This could have been Lloyds moment to build bridges. To say he understands how these CSA victims & their families feel and that he's going to A) educate himself around "sex work" and its cost to the women who engage in it and B) that he's going to get some couples councilling & around porn addiction etc (lord knows he has the money).

    He could have come back even stronger.

    Actually people were surprised Mark was a volunteer and didn't get paid. The only person Lloyd has ever given money to is his professional video editor. One you tuber tweeted he's lost patreon money because he wouldn't come out in support of Lloyd. They have literally replaced eight leaders who must not be questioned with one. Its bizarre for those of us who know him of old.

  • NonCoinCollector
    NonCoinCollector

    A relative of Lloyd's just released a statement on Lloyd grooming 14 year-olds. I am more than just a little upset to see this.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X7lrwCFdllc

  • raymond frantz
    raymond frantz

    All it remains now is to find that girl in Bramhall now.She must 31 years old now

  • raymond frantz
    raymond frantz

    I've already given this information to Mike but since this is out in the public I would like to add that Lloyd's dad is not just a well respected elder in Wilmslow but the most influential that for many years has destroyed other people's lives and driven away people from the congregation.The Co coordinstor of elders is Lloyd's childhood friend they grew up in the same part of town and each others houses. The Co ordinator along with another influential elder I won't name see Jonathan the father as a surrogate father ,they are same age as Lloyd.All 3 of them are totally corrupt and not only they offered Lloyd a hiding place in Wilmslow, our congregation, but also crucial advise how to escape to Croatia and avoid criminal charges.

  • slimboyfat
    slimboyfat

    The testimony from “Marko” is shocking and sounds credible. Especially the bit about Lloyd putting pressure on his wife to “keep it in the family”. It’s horrible to think how his narcissistic rage must be playing out right now. He no doubt blames others, especially his wife for this all coming out.

    Mark O’Donnell’s statement is much appreciated, but I think he should have said that the further allegations against Lloyd are unproven rather than untrue. Because how does Mark know they are untrue? And Kim Silvio should be praised for speaking out. But overall Mark’s statement is good.

    I don’t like the statement from Ortez at all. I don’t care how many hours he has put into the documentary. If he truly puts victims first then he should state categorically that Lloyd will play no part in it. He asks for time to work out the “details”, but excluding Lloyd from the project is not a “detail”. It’s a decision that should have been taken by now. Only swift action could save the project, which he seems unwilling to take. I doubt it will see the light of day now.

  • NonCoinCollector
    NonCoinCollector

    Slimboyfat, give these people time. When you are under the spell of a guy that clearly has the charisma to do what he has done, it takes time to realize what happened. To call Lloyd a cult leader in the making seems to fit. This man was a narcissist and checked nearly every box for sociopath. He could put on a good show and knew what to say to influence people. The man literally weaponized his viewers against Kim Silvio while admitting to some very disgusting things.

    These people were under Lloyd's direct influence and need time. I bet their attitudes will change if given a few weeks.

  • Diogenesister
    Diogenesister

    I knew there was something he was struggling with psychologically, because of the way his weight yo-yo'd from video to video when he made them monthly, or at least less often.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit