Is there a reason why the HS must be One thing only to ALL people?
I know that organized religion would like us to think that, but is that truly the case?
Did Ghandi have the HS?, did MLK jr?
Yes to both I think.
I like to stick with basics and work up from there.
I live in a Post-Enlightenment world and your question is a Pre-Enlightenment question.
The premise that supernatural and invisible beings exist is a huge premise to swallow.
How do we get "there" from here?
Further, when we make such guesses about the activity/influence of such an invisible/intangible supernatural "persons" we are doing something I find inadvisable to do.
We operate out of ignorance rather than information.
It is difficult enought to decide important questions with a solid knowledge base with established data.
But--to speculate about the unknown (and unknowable) as to what possible influece these "beings" may have----well, that is way to
Pre-Enlightenment for me to tackle.
Even the most ardent Theological expert is hard-pressed to speak knowingly about the character known as HOLY SPIRIT or HOLY GHOST.
Alas! If a discussion devolves down to speculating about Ghosts-----aren't we in the same arena as Loch Ness monsters, Bigfoot and UFO kidnappings?
I'm not trying to ridicule your query; far from it. I'm just telling you where I am at.