Jesus not crucified on torture stake. Impossible!

by sacolton 250 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • reniaa
    reniaa

    lol I didn't abandon this thread I still don't agree with leolaia I think the evolvement of stauros and xylon and crux show they were defined as a simple instrument of death and stake being it's defining point and that to in going beyond that to cross with crosspiece assumed, especially by the definition of cross as it stands now is beyond the bible wording. no one would ever assume it could mean Jesus did die on a stake without crosspiece but also it brings unwarranted attention to the shape of his death instrument.

    The problem is the writers in using the term stauros were talking about Jesus death not about the shape of his death instrument. Cross takes it to a shape which is not what the context of the bible or what the writers intended shows. the fact Jesus used this ambiguous word before he even died shows it wasn't about a particular shape but about a his dying.

    I'm trying to think of an example if you say someone dies in a car crash but then say actually he died by such and such car and start wearing the car that killed him around your neck as a symbol this is not hat the writer intended. It is clear leolaia that the writers did not want it to be clear on what Jesus died on other than he died executed roman style and at the time of Jesus's death this was defined as stake/pale /tree but with execution/torture thrown in. Cross goes beyond this and even you agree but your justify this by saying it is likely that he died with a crosspiece so it is ok to assume a crosspiece.

    If you can prove leolaia that when people read cross they can know it also can mean simple stake nowadays maybe you have a point for saying cross is ok but you argue the opposite that stake is incorrect because it doesn't say crosspiece but as I showed they writers never thought in terms of the crosspiece in time they wrote that word so stake is more correct from the way they viewed the words then as stake/pale/tree.

  • purplesofa
    purplesofa

    I was wondering what renaii's post is from a day ago,

    I cannot see it,

    purps

  • Colton
    Colton

    Thread broken again? Can't see the last post.

  • Narkissos
    Narkissos

    Last post I can see on this thread is purplesofa's, "3 days ago".

  • Narkissos
    Narkissos

    Still...

  • Narkissos
    Narkissos

    Next try: at some point what was posted in the meantime should appear...ยจ

    Edit: that's it!

  • Mary
    Mary

    After seeing the stupid, braindead comments from Reniaa ignoring the obvious fact that Jesus died on a cross, I figured I dedicate a song to her:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOKK8mAkiUI

  • OUTLAW
    OUTLAW

    LOL!!@ Mary!!.............Mary..That song is perfect for Reniaa..Who else would think about wearing a car around her neck?..LOL!!...........The same car that killed Jesus!!................LOL!!...OUTLAW

  • Vanderhoven7
    Vanderhoven7

    marked

  • DATA-DOG
    DATA-DOG

    It's very interesting that the WTBTS only shows one of these illustrations.. Can you guess which one?!

    I am no Historian, and I never crucified anyone, but I see that it would make sense to have permanent upright poles at the execution site. Why would you do everything all over each time you had to execute someone? Rome was efficient, so it makes sense that the victim would be forced to carrry the cross-beam to the execution site. If The Passion's depiction of Jesus' torture prior to his execution is remotely accurate, then there is no way he could have carried a 300lb wooden instrument of death after what he went through.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit