Does your past define you?

by Princess 20 Replies latest jw friends

  • Princess
    Princess

    They were discussing this on the radio this morning. Are you defined by what you have done in your past, or is it the present experiences that define you?

    The DJ and Tracey Lawrence (country singer) were trying to emphasize that we are defined by what we do NOW as opposed to our past.

    Are we as a group here an exception? Is our past cult experience enough to define us differently?

    I feel I am so different now, possibly as a result of being raised a dub for 27 years, possibly because I'm finally discovering who I would have been. I have so many goals currently that I'm able to work toward and fulfill that I can't waste time thinking about the past and letting it shape me. I agree with the radio guys. I feel I'm more defined by what I'm doing NOW but maybe still have a little of the past as an influence in what I have become.

    What do you think?

    Rachel

  • stillajwexelder
    stillajwexelder

    Everybody on this planet is defined by his or her past to a degree -- no matter how small a degree IMHO

  • Lady Lee
    Lady Lee

    Rachel I think a bit of both plus my goals for the future and perhaps maybe even more the future than the present or the past. My future holds the image of who I want to be and how I want my life to be. Those goals define the direction I want to take and the choices I make today to get there.

    The past is more about who I was and where I was in my life. Still a part of me that I use in the present to work towards the future

  • Xena
    Xena

    Who we are now is defined by the sum total of our experiences to-date. Who we will be is determined by what we do with this information.

    IMHO anyway

  • maxwell
    maxwell

    I was reading Dear Abby and someone wrote in about a guy who was 17 and had a gf who was about 15. He turned 18 and the parents of the girl turned him in for statutory rape. According to the story, wherever he goes now he will have to register as a sex offender. It seems his past will follow him around and be a significant part of defining who he is.

    I think faults can have a bigger effect on who you are no matter when they happen. Past mistakes can follow you around for a long time, whereas good you have done in the past can be completely engulfed or ignored because of a present fault.

  • Sassy
    Sassy

    Good thread! I think it is easy when we have been traumitzed by the WTS, especially if raised in it, to let it be our crutch. What a shame it would be though to allow it. It is true, we can't change the past and we can't know for sure what kind of person we might have been if we had never been JWs, but I would like to think who we are inside and evolved to, if we allow it, can indeed be who we might have been any way.

    I think we need to be careful not to dwell so much on the past that we don't look ahead, but if we have goals and iniatives of where we want to go or do with our lives or who we want to be, then we can have a positive control over our current lives.

    I'm really happy right now with who I am and what I am doing in my life. This is something I don't know if I really could say that when I was a JW.

  • Nosferatu
    Nosferatu

    I agree with stillajwexelder. Our past has some kind of effect on what we are today. If it didn't, we'd be going back and making the same stupid mistakes. When we learn from our past, we move ahead.

  • Strawberryfieldsforever
    Strawberryfieldsforever

    I'm with you Sassy. You can't change the past. It stays with you and you can't keep looking back wondering what you might have been or done. I think my past helped me to be more independent. I was always a follower and never questioned. Now I am very independent and making my life what I want it to be. As much as I dislike the way I was brought up in the religion, I'm going to try to go on and not use it for a crutch. But we all know........it's very hard to do sometimes.

  • franklin J
    franklin J

    my past as a JW does not define me in the least.

    It is however, part of who I am; a collective set of early life experiences of which I clearly remember. My later experiences in life after leaving the JW set of beliefs is part of my definition of character; profession; relationships. They all came AFTER, and have thus made me who and what I am today. My thinking and perspective on life is radically different.

    I post on this forum because I enjoy the camaraderie of knowing others have had similar experiences to mine.

    Frank

  • Purple
    Purple

    A course I have attended says that the decisions we made in the past shape our future and can stand in our way. They used an example of a child who has one bad experience with a subject say maths, fails miserably or has a challenge they cant meet or overcome and decides that they are hopeless at maths and cannot do it. SO for the next 20 years when maths in involved the person fails in that area, avoids it like the plauge and so on. Yet when they examined that decision later on in life they discovered that infact they could do the math they thought they couldnt do and went into a completley different field, accounting and excelled at it. So that one decision shaped that persons life for 20 years. In this case you could definitely argue that the past shaped the future.

    We also act from what we know from past experience. A simple illustration is that we learn from a young age that if we touch something hot we will burn ourselves, yet every child does it once. However that one experience taught us a valuable lesson that the average person learns from and that changes maybe future outcomes. So expereince does teach us and adds to our knowledge and helps shape who we are.

    On a personal level I have had one very bad experience in relationships which now stops me from developing new ones and I am working on changing it, but experince has also tauight me that if you block people out of your life and you close your life to new experiences and opportuinties and people, you will have an empty uninteresting life, one could almost say half lived!

    So yes I am the person I am because of my past, but I can choose to go beyond that past, learn lessons, take what I need from it but then I can move beyond it and in the future create a new past! I hope that makes some sense!

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit