fleaman said:
Sorry, but im struggling to see what is wrong with the advice given?
I have not read this whole thread but....
...Back in 2003 I got a professional opinion of the advice in the 'Great Teacher' book...She thought some of it was very bad and some of it was good....Overall, she said the pages I asked her to read were " Totally inappropriate" for children .
http://www.jehovahs-witness.net/watchtower/child-abuse/55720/1/I-got-a-Professional-Opinion-of-Great-Teacher-book
Here is what I reported back then:
"I will tell you a little about her (the therapist): She is a well respected member of the community and runs a moderate size local not-for-profit organization that cares for children in the community who have been abused, have been through trauma or have other needs for support.She and her organization also work with parents, couples and individuals.In her separate, private practice, she also sees numerous children and adults who have been abused, and has been in private practice since 1977.
"I asked her to review the material because while Ithought it was terrible,I very much wanted a professional opinion because I have many biases against the WTBTS.
"After reading the first complete paragraph on page 170, she said, “But God doesn’t always protect His children.”
"After reading the second paragraph she noted how they made a big deal over ‘the opposite sex’ when defining correct adult sex.
"After reading the third paragraph, she said, “This is totally inappropriate as it implies that the little kid is going to turn into a pervert or something.Not good at all.”
"After reading the fourth paragraph, she look disgusted about many things but only said, “Interesting how they keep tying Satan and demons into the whole thing,” (shaking her head.)She said it was very good that it says clearly that the abuse is wrong. (the last sentence on page 170.)
"She said nothing at all about the first paragraph on page 171.
"Regarding the second paragraph on 171, she said, “Many, many 5- or 6-year-olds simply cannot say, ‘stop that!’”Some would be able to do this, but many cannot.Especially if it is their father or someone very close to them that they love.”Then she said, “It is good that it says the child should tell on the abuser no matter what."
"When she was done reading she mentioned again that she was very disturbed by the third paragraph on page 170, and handed the scans back to me.
"I asked her if a child had been abused and then read this if it would make the child feel that the abuse was their own fault and she said, “Exactly!”
"I asked her if all in all she agreed that these pages were inappropriate for children and she said, “Absolutely!Totally inappropriate!”