The first church I went to was a church that had two services. One was contemporary and had the lights down low/rock band onstage/worship leader who would ask you to put your hands in the air and get on your knees and such. The other service was more traditional. Regular lighting/organ/piano/worship leader would just say "Stand and let's sing number 256 in your hymnal, "Joy to the Lord"'
I began to go to the contemporary one. I loved it. Just coming out of the JWs, my spiritual journey was like a roller coaster and emotional. The music gave me a chance to sing out some of my emotions I was feeling to God. But you just can't expect that same emotional responose time and time again. Your relationship with God will change as you grow. It reminds me of a new relationship with your husband. You start out giddy and in love -- butterflies. But as you grow together, you have a more steady, lasting, respect and appreciation.
As I progressed, my spiritual journey became more like a slow steady ride in God's arms and I quit living a roller coaster. Many of the calls for "emotional manipulation" I couldn't feel because I was on meat and I didn't feel the same emotions. For example, once the pastor called everyone who needed hope to get own their knees and pray. People were on their knees, crying, praying. I had hope. I had faith and I didn't need to ask God for hope because I had a strong hope in His promises. I eventually got frustrated at the constant calls for emotions I didn't have. I was feeling like singing out in praise and joy and quiet meditation on Him was what was genuine in my heart.
I moved churches to a traditional church. This one seems to encourage my natural emotions and I feel much more sincere in worship. It also seems much more RESPECTFUL. I feel like God is worshipped as a glorious mighty Father and King who is sovereign instead of worshipped as a friend who will pat your back and tell you it is ok.