What's a word that describes the way Witnesses behave as a group?

atomant

Another word comes to mind ( suckers).
LongHairGal

Paranoid conformity.
and, yes, Mrs. Flipper, they are damaging and dishonest!
punkofnice

did I miss Sheeple, anywhere?
Witchettygrub

A 'peculiar people' from 1Peter 2:9.
MarkofCane

Pharisaical; practicing or advocating strict observance of external forms and ceremonies of religion or conduct without regard to the spirit; self-righteous; hypocritical.
I feel this fits pretty good too
Heaven

Did I miss "Watchtarded"?
Vidiot

"Insular" works for me.
flipper

Paul you stated, " I'm looking for a neutral word that doesn't necessarily connote negativity " . Good luck on that then. Most words that describe what JW's and the WT Society are about - denote negativity. My thoughts like Beth Sarim " CONTROLLED ". "Controlled " would be the positive spin word for " enslaved " - if you're looking for a silver lining of positivity
flipper

Here's another one that I use all the time. " Criminal. " I know it's not positive - but what the hell- it's honest
Lostandfound

Not a flock (of sheep) but
A HERD Mindless heavy cattle trampling on anyone that gets in the way.