There are criticisms from time to time......like er....fluff! Not enough WT/JW attacking stuff. etc. etc. (yawn) I don't quite see it that way. This place is principally for XJws. I think a great deal of us deserve a break! It maybe to vent some anger, pass along some humourous tale or develop friendships with other posters. We might want to just relax with friends, so to speak. It maybe that the topic lines lack serious dub-hitting material...but what the heck. There are other things being acheived. The board serves social functions as well so you have to post what maybe described as 'fluff'. Thats how people interact in RL and develop understanding and relationships. with each other.
I wouldn't worry about booting dubs with every topic line. Its the humane aspect of the board that will appeal to some. So we will all have our place and shouldn't feel inadequate or self conscious that what we may or may not say is not good enough. That would be an unfortunate echo from our lives as dubs, if it was, as would the negative assessment of others. How many times did you have to put up with that as a dub?