WE SHALL OVERCOME ! WE ARE NOT AFRAID !

by Phizzy 12 Replies latest jw friends

  • Quendi
    Quendi

    I marvel at you, BOTR. Maybe your training as a lawyer has made you incapable of giving a simple answer to a question or assertion. Or perhaps you are simply in too big a hurry to make your own statements without reading others' words. In any case, I challenged your statement that those of us who lived in the American South during the Civil Rights era should have been so paralyzed by fear that it would have taken insanity not to have felt anythng else. I gave you examples of why this was not true from my own family history to contradict your statement. Your reply was to talk about your work and acquaintances as well as life in Newark, New Jersey. None of that is relevant to my point.

    Please read carefully before responding because you do yourself a disservice otherwise. Your latest reply only underscores this. You failed to address my original point. Instead, you went off on a tangent, talking about your reading and how this has made you an expert. I pointed to the actual lives of friends and family to say that murder, mayhem, intimidation and unjust law did not stop us. I would say thst our experience outweighs your reading by a long, long way.

    The song "We Shall Overcome" has lyrics which state, "We are not afraid." We certainly weren't. To have felt no fear didn't mean we were "crazy" as you asserted in your first post on this thread. It meant we had the courage of our convictions and weren't going to be intimidated, willing even to face death if necessary because we believed our cause was just. And that was the entire point I wanted to make and which you seemingly failed to grasp.

    Quendi

  • rebel8
    rebel8

    We Shall Overcome actually started as a labor protest song.

  • Band on the Run
    Band on the Run

    I don't think you are saying anything contrary. Perhaps I should phrased my comment more clearly. I know with absolute certainty that the civil rights workers were afraid. The point was that you did it anyway. The movement emerged from Black Southern churches, particularly the Baptists. People met for church services and hymn singing before an action. They knew they would meet with violence. It was discussed openly. I don't believe you would be allowed to participate if you were not conscious of the likelihood of violence. They were selective in choosing protesters. People were required to dress as if for church.

    I don't believe we disagree. It was always more dangerous in the South. They did not like white Northerners or college students, too. The presence of white Northern college students probably did not help matters. Jehovah's Witnesses were evil outsiders, too.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit