The (ancient) globalised world - Ancient Israel imported cinnamon from India

by fulltimestudent 12 Replies latest social current

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    One of my specific interests (when I started at University) was the interconnectiveness of the ancient world. And the more I've learned in the past 6 years, the more I've seen that the ancient Euro/Asian world was connected. A network of trading routes and markets exchanged goods and wealth, and along with the traded items went traded ideas and concepts. Few concepts seemed to have developed in isolation.

    But here is a surprising discovery, a number of ancient flasks containing residue from cinnamon have been found. Here's a media summary.

    Archaeologists Find Israel Was Land of Milk, Honey - and Cinnamon.

    Israel is known to have been on the route of ancient spice trade, but archaeologists now think that at least one of the spices - cinnamon - was made in Israel at the time.

    By: Jewish Press Staff

    Published: August 22nd, 2013

    Bark from Cinnamomum verum, which is found naturally in southern India, Sri Lanka and Myanmar; another form of cinnamon comes from Cinnamomum cassia, found naturally in China,  Vietnam, Laos and Myanmar.

    Bark from Cinnamomum verum, which is found naturally in southern India, Sri Lanka and Myanmar; another form of cinnamon comes from Cinnamomum cassia, found naturally in China, Vietnam, Laos and Myanmar. Photo Credit: Photo by H. Zell

    Cinnamon, once thought to have been carried on trade routes in ancient Israel, may have been made along the northern Israeli coast and not just in Africa and India, as previously thought, Israeli researchers told LiveScience.

    They analyzed 27 flasks from archaeological sites in Israel dating back 3,000 years and found that the compound that gives cinnamon its flavor was in 10 of the containers.

    Cinnamon bark is found in southern India, and another form of the spice is found in China and southeast Asia. It is now yet known the source of the cinnamon in the flasks found in Israel, but the discovery that it probably was made in Israel "raises the intriguing possibility that long-range spice trade from the Far East westward may have taken place some 3,000 years ago," the Tel Aviv University and Weizmann Institute researchers wrote in a paper to be published in the journal Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry.

    "We don't think they sailed directly [to the Far East]; it was a very hard task even in the 16th century A.D." Dvory Namdar, a researcher with the Weizmann Institute of Science and Tel Aviv University, told LiveScience in an interview.

    Namdar and research colleague Ayelet Gilboa of the University of Haifa said the flasks, which at that time were in area that was part of ancient Phoenicia, feature a narrow opening with thick walls, indicating their contents were highly prized. Flasks with similar shapes previously have been found in temple storerooms and treasuries of ancient kingdoms, the researches added.

    They think that the cinnamon bark was brought from the Far East to ancient Israel and mixed with liquids before it was placed in the flasks prior to shipping the spice elsewhere. Namdar and Gilboa speculate that people of the time mixed the cinnamon in with wine. "If you mix it with a bigger [container of wine], then you get flavored wine," they said.

    Read more at: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/archaeologists-find-israel-was-land-of-milk-honey-and-cinnamon/2013/08/22/

  • fulltimestudent
  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    The report is not quite clear in its claim. As read, the statement, " archaeologists now think that at least one of the spices - cinnamon - was made in Israel at the time." Seems to suggest that the cinnamon was produced in areas along the eastern Mediterranean coastline. There is no evidence for that. But there is evidence that imported cinnamon was mixed into other products to produce cinnamon flavoured products, perhaps wine (as an example).

    You may also note that while the report names Israel as the source of the manufactured, cinnamon flavoured product, it clarifies that statement by saying that at that time, 3000 years ago, the area was part of ancient Phoenicia.

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    How did this spice (and others) get from South (or S.E.Asia) to the west Asian coast?

    Maybe we will never know that, but it most likely moved from trading market to trading market. This ancient city in southern Arabia (now deserted) was apparently heavily involved in the ancient spice trade.

    http://popular-archaeology.com/issue/june-2013/article/rare-southern-arabian-artifacts-find-home-at-smithsonians-sackler-gallery

    POPULAR ARCHEOLOGY: Vol. 11 June 2013

    Rare Southern Arabian Artifacts Find Home at Smithsonian’s Sackler Gallery

    Thu, Aug 22, 2013

    History Preserved in Sand Reveals Clues to the Ancient Qataban Civilization

    T he Arthur M. Sackler Gallery today announced a gift of 374 ancient Arabian artifacts from the American Foundation for the Study of Man (AFSM). Dating from the eighth century B.C. to the second century A.D., the objects were unearthed at the ancient city of Tamna in Yemen and provide invaluable insight into the little-known history of the southern Arabian Peninsula. The collection was assembled by American archaeology pioneer Wendell Phillips in the early 1950s. Together with a team of renowned archaeologists, Phillips compiled thorough excavation records, creating one of the few fully documented collections of Qataban artifacts available to researchers that are invaluable to future study of the region.

    The donation of the complete Qataban collection to the Sackler is made possible by Merilyn Phillips Hodgson, president of the AFSM and sister of the late Wendell Phillips.

    “This collection provides the Sackler with a tremendous opportunity to shed light on the rich history and culture of ancient Arabia, and to do so through the discoveries of one of the most remarkable early archeologists, Wendell Phillips,” said Julian Raby, The Dame Jillian Sackler Director of the Arthur M. Sackler Gallery and the Freer Gallery of Art.

    Once admired for its fragrant and abundant foliage and lush pastures, the Qataban empire of the late first millennium B.C. was a hub of cultural exchange, central to the ancient trade routes that extended from the Mediterranean Sea to the Indian Ocean. Tamna was its bustling capital city and reached its peak between the fifth century B.C. and first century A.D., when a mysterious catastrophic fire destroyed the city, leaving it buried under layers of ash and sand for almost two millennia.

    Tamna remained largely undiscovered until the 1950s, when Phillips, a paleontologist, geologist and a self-taught archaeologist, gathered a team and began systematic excavations to unearth and record artifacts using methods that are standard archaeological practices today. His technical methods in excavation and detailed field notes have been critical to the study of ancient Arabia and have laid the groundwork for more recent explorations. Highlights among Phillips’ discoveries are a pair of striking bronze lions with the figure of Eros, the Greek god of love, on their backs. Known as the “Lions of Tamna,” the skillfully cast sculptural forms exemplify the vibrant cultural exchange between the Qataban and Greek empires. Another collection highlight is a translucent alabaster head of a young woman, with lapis lazuli eyebrows and an Egyptian-style hairstyle. Unearthed in the cemetery of Tamna, the head was named “Miriam” after the daughter of a member of the expedition

    ___________________________________________________________________

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    Where does that information lead us?

    It leads to the possibility of the exchange of ideas, doesnt it?

  • doofdaddy
    doofdaddy

    While wandering through a museum in Bangkok, I was stunned to see a Roman oil lamp! It was still being used for lighting in a Buddhist temple up to a hundred years ago. It is believed to have been traded along the Silk Road over the centuries.

  • Phizzy
    Phizzy

    The exchange of ideas is evident in the religions and pholosophies of the near east, which bear close resemblance to those of the Far East, India etc.

    As you say, ideas do not generally seem to grow in isolation, though the flash of genius that is a new idea had to start somewhere.

    I think it is fascinating to think that Judaism particularly from the time of the return from Babylon, down through the first century AD, was exposed to the thinking from many sources, and so were the various movements who adopted the Christ figure, both Jews and Gentiles. (Christians)

    Hence the teaching of the Golden Rule, as explained by Rabbi Hillel, and the Gospels claim, later by "Jesus", probably was absorbed from the Far East, where it had been taught in many religions and philosophies for centuries. This would be true for many other ideas too, particularly religious ones.

  • HowTheBibleWasInvented
    HowTheBibleWasInvented

    What time-frame? If you are at university you know Israel didn't become a Kingdom until Omri.... Before that they were under poor leaders or Egyptian vassels. (David-Solomon were Judean not Israelite... there never was a united kingdom) Futher before Jeroboam I (who came in after Shishak's invasion) there was Saul and previous leaders like Labaya (Abimelech of Judges 9 maybe) Unless these finds are from after 850BCE they were mostly likely Egyptian trade.

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    Thank you for posting your thoughts, HTBWI.

    You asked what time frame? The report stated 3000 years ago.

    Where? The report again made a point of saying that the area was then ancient Phoenicia.

    If the dating is reasonably accurate, it is difficult to identify the source.

  • fulltimestudent
    fulltimestudent

    Another example of export/import and product spread that influenced the world.

    From the Turkish Hurriyet Daily News:

    http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/the-blue-white-ceramics-of-china-and-iznik.aspx?pageID=238&nID=53981&NewsCatID=375

    HURRIYET DAILY NEWS

    The blue-white ceramics of China and Iznik

    Niki GAMM - Hürriyet Daily News

    One of the areas to which blue-white Chinese porcelain was exported was Istanbul and in particular to the imperial court at Topkapi Palace. The first use of Chinese porcelain was in 1457

    Blue-white pottery refers to the elegantly painted, blue and white Chinese and Iznik tiles and ceramics that were and are highly prized by their owners. Their journey has been a long one, starting with the discovery of cobalt blue in Iran that was mined from the 9th century CE and exported to China mostly as a raw material. There are, however, a very few examples of blue-white pottery that have been found in Iran, with Arabic inscriptions on them from about the same period, suggesting that the blue-white technique went along with the raw material.

    The first Chinese blue-white also occur in the 9th century although only fragments have been found. The earthenware continued to be used and admired until it reached an apex in the 14th century. By then, blue-white was being extensively exported to other lands in the Far East and along the famed Silk Road, thanks to the spread of Islam. Early in the 14th century, the blue-white technique was applied to porcelain and the results produced were filled with floral and geometric patterns that suited Muslim tastes. Better quality cobalt blue from Persia contributed to the finer designs. Robert Finlay, in his book “The Pilgrim Art,” notes that cobalt blue went for twice the price of gold.

    First use of Chinese porcelain

    One of the areas to which blue-white Chinese porcelain was exported was Istanbul, and in particular to the imperial court at Topkapi Palace. The first recorded of Chinese porcelain was in 1457 at the circumcision ceremonies for Fatih Sultan Mehmed II’s two sons, Bayezid and Mustafa, but we aren’t told if these were blue-white. An inventory at Topkapi in 1496 is the first time porcelain is mentioned in that location. The total collection at Topkapi, achieved through war, plunder, gifts and unclaimed inheritance, numbers more than 10,000. Of this, more than half of these are blue-whites and represent a timeframe dating from the middle of the 14th century to the nineteenth.

    Alongside the Chinese porcelain are the blue-white tiles and porcelain produced at Iznik from the first half of the 15th century to the middle of the 16th. These were at first based on fifteenth century Ming dynasty porcelains that included flowers, clouds and even dragons. Iznik was the first Turkish capital in Anatolia and it never lost its importance in the Ottoman period for its successful production of tiles.

    Topkapi Palace supported Iznik tile-making, gradually increasing the orders it placed with ateliers there.
    Ceramic items for daily use are to be found in the Topkapi kitchens and on the tables of the wealthy.

    Iznik tiles were also exported even through special offers from abroad. In the recently published book “Turkish Tiles” by Ozlem Inay Erten and Oguz Erten, the authors noted that the palace kitchen registers dated 1582 show that 541 Iznik plates and cooking pans were purchased from the Istanbul market for the circumcision of Sultan Murad III’s son Prince Mehmed.

    In fact, the Iznik ceramics were fashionable throughout the Mediterranean, the Balkans and Europe. The early works produced in Italy seemed to have been a mixture of Islamic and Chinese designs which would hardly be surprising as both would have arrived there via the Ottoman Empire in the 16th century. Direct imitation of the Chinese ware, however, had to wait until the next century when civil disturbances in China disrupted trade. The Italians then turned to copying from already extant pieces and after the Italians the production of ceramic wares began to emerge in the Netherlands.

    In a recent CNN interview with the Netherlands’ 360-year-old Royal Delft Group CEO Henk Schouten, the point was made that “Royal Delft itself was influenced by Chinese pottery, after Dutch tradesmen brought back porcelain from the Far East in the 1600s. It proved popular with the Dutch, and potters began developing a similar style with local clay.” This was the result of Dutch trading directly with the Far East. Today blue-white Delft ware is among the finest produced throughout the world.
    Technique matters
    Blue-white may be divided into four types including the best tiles produced in Iznik in the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries. They can be either blue on white or white on blue on smooth, hard dough. The transparent underglazing has differing shades of blue for such designs as flowers, stylized clouds and dragons that show the influence of the Chinese. In some cases kufic and nesih calligraphy appears. Between 1520 and 1540 turquoise was added from time to time to the blue-white.
    Rare blue-white ceramics

    The best of the blue-white ceramics are the extremely rare examples in which delicate flowers and tiny leaves form a chain around a spiral. This design for a long time was called “Golden Horn” ware but now that many examples have been found in excavations in Iznik it is acknowledged that the center of production was Iznik.

    Underglazing, a basic method applied for centuries in Anatolia, is used to produce the stunning blue-white porcelain. It consists of firing the clay that has been molded or hand-shaped into the desired form and glazed with a tin-based glaze. It is then taken out, cooled and painted with designs which are applied by drawing them on paper and then pricking small holes in the paper. The paper is then fitted over the clay surface and charcoal dust poured over it. This leaves the design right on the clay surface, ready for the paint to be applied. Once the painting is finished, a colored or colorless tine-based glaze is applied over it and it’s re-fired.

    For those people interested in blue-white Iznik and Chinese porcelain, Topkapi Palace Museum has examples in its Çinili Kösk (Tile Villa) located on the grounds of the Istanbul Archaeological Museums. By the end of the year the Topkapi kitchens should once again be open to the public where the palace collection of Chinese porcelains will be on display. It has the largest collection of Chinese porcelain outside of China. Another place in Istanbul where Iznik tiles and Chinese porcelain can be seen, according to its website, is “the Sadberk Hanim Museum which has one of the leading collections in the world.

    Iznik ceramics on display including wares for daily use like plates, bowls, vases and jugs decorated in a naturalistic style with rose, tulip, carnation and hyacinths motifs and tiles manufactured for mosques, tombs, madrasahs, hammams with designs prepared in the palace workshop, show the development in Iznik ceramic art from the end of 15th till the middle of the 17th century.

    Sadberk Hanim Museum’s collection of Chinese porcelain is a modest one, but it includes unique pieces. The collection is an important treasure for the ones who are interested in examining the Chinese porcelains used during the Ottoman period.”

    September/07/2013

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit