Clearly, any JW apologist or JW friendly person who posts on this forum knows full well they are breaking their own organization's policies. Everything else is mere detail.
Even before the send button is struck, the JW knows they are doing something the organization has told them not to do. But they have disobeyed. They have disregarded the "wise" counsel. They have spat out that part of the food in due season. Nothing else matters. They have broken the rules.
On that basis alone they are engaging in hypocritical behavior. They want to do a Jeremiah or Ezekiel on us: Dump and run. But the organization tells them they should not. It is not their job. They have to control their urges to hit back, to show restraint.
Possibly worse than their hypocrisy is their lack of faith in either their all-powerful God's ability to sanctify his name or the Governing Body's ability to take care of the flock through warnings.
Moreover, for a JW to still comment - even if it is a Jeremiad dump and run - tells us a lot about the JWs poor emotion regulation: They have failed to control the urge to hit back. They have fallen into temptation. Their faith is not equal to their forbidden urges.
And, in their hypocrisy, their lack of faith in their God and their organization and in their poor emotion regulation, they reveal who and what they are.
The best response from any of us - who are not under any such GB instructions - is to congratulate these JWs on being at odds with their proclaimed - if not shouted - faith in the organization. The only difference between them and us is one of degrees of defiance. That is all. Period.
Thank goodness the back door exit for their kingdom hall is sufficiently wide for them to carry their shameful secret as they slink into the night air back home to their laptop secrets.
Yes, to all you JW's who post denunciatory comments to apostates on this and other sites, Jehovah is watching you and waiting. And, take it from Jeremiah and Ezekiel, he is very angry with you. You have been warned.