Pretend you're a faithful witness and devils advocate these arguments for me to help fine tune them:
Fallacy of perfection:
"There will be no more sickness and death in the new earth..."
unless of course you sin, then you will die.
But there won't be pain and suffering.... so we just won't care if our loved one dies even if they sinned?
What happens if someone commits murder? Does God prevent them from murdering? If so that would mean they don't have free will. If God allows them to murder, and resurrects the person they killed, what about the pain they felt when they were killed? Are they given "spiritual morphine" to cope with it? Is their memory erased?
I had it argued that our desire to sin would be erased, but obviously being perfect doesn't stop that because Adam and Eve were perfect.
"But they gave in to temptation" I was told.
How is that any different from now? Does perfection = superior self control and intelligence?
Further, what about malicious intent? Satan supposedly loves to do really messed up things, yet he was originally perfect. He didn't give in to temptation, he was deviant and warped. What is to say people in the new system won't be like this? How can you prevent them from practicing their deivation without limiting free will?
Furthermore let's critically analyze perfection:
You eliminate sickness, easily done.
You eliminate death... not so easily done.
There are two ways you can die if sickness is out of the picture, accidents and malice (suicide included in malice).
In order to prevent malice, you would have to limit free will which I discussed above.
But what about limiting accidents?
Today in our present condition, you would be conisdered negligent if you left your car in neutral on a hill and it rolled down the hill and killed someone.
In the "new system" when we are "perfect" we would need to have superior intellect to calculate advanced cause and effect to prevent accidents. For example:
Parking your truck in a specific spot might be negligent, because exactly a week later a tornado would come and blow your truck into your house killing your brother while he sits in his favorite chair. In our current level of intelligence and ability to calculate cause and effect, leaving a car in neutral on a hill would be considered negligent, but parking your car where a tornado will pick it up a week later would be considered a freak accident.
If Jehovah gave us superior intellect to calculate advanced cause and effect, it might be considered negligent to not forsee a tornado a week later tossing our truck into someone.
So everything is fine and dandy right?
Wrong!
Intelligence is directly proportionate to ability to calculate cause and effect. Unless you have INFINITE intelligence you will never be able to prevent accidents completely, you might be able to reduce them to a very low amount but they will never be completely eliminated unless you have INFINITE intelligence to calculate the INFINITE possibilities of every action.
For example, you could park your truck there and realize that it is safe there from all tornados for the next week, year, decade, century etc. But since your intelligence is directly proportionate to how far in the future you could predict (by an unknown ratio to us lowly humans), you would never be able to completely eliminate accidents unless your intelligence is infinite.
So Jehovah would give us infinite intelligence/wisdom right?
But Jehovahs wisdom/intelligence is infinite!
We will NEVER be equal to Jehovah in wisdom. The bible constantly reinforces his wisdom and intelligence is unmatched, so this could not happen.
There is no way for both us and Jehovah to have infinite intelligence/wisdom and Jehovah to still be more wise/intelligent than us.
Infinity = Infinity, it is as whole and legitimate as any real integer. There is no such thing as a lesser infinity, therefore saying that Jehovah has greater infinite wisdom than us is like saying that a light is on and off at the same time, or that I am exactly six feet tall and you are exactly six feet tall but you are taller than me.
If we are not infinitely intelligent/wise we could not prevent ALL accidents from happening on our own. Therefore Jehovah would have to intervene in our lives to prevent them, essentially removing our free will.
In order to make us truly immortal and autonomous, we would need wisdom and intelligence equal to his which would not happen.
You might argue that we won't have free will, but this would be against God's purpose as if he didn't want us to have free will then what logic would there be for him allowing Satan to run wild and all the suffering we experience daily?
I won't even begin to touch the argument of "Jehovah cannot lie" yet "Jehovah is all powerful", most sane Christians respond that he can lie but choose not to. Witnesses seem convinced he cannot lie.