Please don't feel at any moment that I am arguing against your answers. I am in no way considering acting on this. This is the very reason for the thread itself. To pass judgement on the method.
With that said, I agree that forcing someone is only counter productive, but for that, they need to be aware that they are being forced. At no point did I mentioned that the said site would look like anything known and sneaky.
As far as my case, yes, it would have worked, so far I was not aware that someone was shoveling down something down my throat. Funny experience, the first time I bumped into this website, many many years ago, it was by accident. Not that I was looking for "apostate" material either. One day I wondered if the society had a site of its own so I ran a search. No doubt in my mind that I was in the right organization at that time and besides, apostate talk at meeting was not as prevailing back then. When I clicked on the link I knew I was not in an official JW site, but I also did not think apostates were already online. To top it off, it seemed like everyone at the time, on this site, had just come back from an assembly and were posting comments about it. May be it was my unawareness or naiveness, but it took me a while and had to read several comments before I realized it was not a pro-JW site. Had it been just a simple copy of a pre-1975 magazine, and it would have raised serious questions.
Thanks everyone for your comments.