Disfellowshipping: A protection in the end?

by Esmeralda 21 Replies latest jw friends

  • Esmeralda
    Esmeralda

    Hi all,

    Well, the year is nearly out, and as the new one approaches I'm thinking back on 2 years of being in the online exJW community and, in June 2002, my four year anniversary of my df'ing.

    When first I came to H2O seeking comfort and support in January 2000, I had been df'd for a year and a half and online nearly 4 years but never had the guts to type "Jehovah's Witnesses" into a search engine. That search led me to Freeminds (thanks, Randy *hug*) and then, to H2O.

    What a journey its been. I've gone from devastation at losing my family, to anger, through the anger to numbness, back through sadness, and now after much soul searching and a chance change of circumstances last summer, come to look at my disfellowshipping in an entirely new light.

    Those who know my history know that I was born into the Borg, baptized at 12, married at 19, and was a very loyal, unquestioning dub until the age of 24 when the elders told me that my miscarried babies had no status with God. No hope of a future, nothing. I had known in the back of my mind this was the Society's view but when I was grieving, the idea caused such rage inside of me that the unwavering faith I'd had in everything the org said being divine caught fire.

    It burned down from there.

    When I finally ended up disfellowshipped after attempting to da myself (see my website for the full gory details) I was devastated that my family was shunning me. Even though a few members chose to ignore that counsel (My jw sister, my mother, and recently, my grandmother) most of the family made it painfully obvious that I was persona non grata to them.

    Last summer, when my father became suddenly, critically ill, the family was once again forced to deal with me, since my sister and I were keeping vigil by my father's bedside, in shifts, 24 hours a day. Some took every pot-shot they could at me, some ignored me as if I wasn't standing by the bed.

    However they reacted to me, though, they were forced to acknowledge and meet my second husband and to see (no matter how they tried to deny it) that he is a wonderful, loving man. Even my hard-nosed elder uncle admitted to my mother that he was very impressed by the way that my husband cared for my father during the hospitalization and after, when he stayed with us for six weeks. It also spoke volumes that my father was, and felt, more welcome in the home of his disfellowshipped daughter than the one who was "faithful" and married to an elder (who, consequently, did not want my father staying with them).

    During the time my father stayed with us, some of my extended family even went so far as to come to my house to visit him. One evening, my uncle, aunt and a cousin played cards with my Dad (at the doctor's request, to test his memory) and drank coffee, ate doughnuts, and looked at my wedding pictures. For three hours, it was almost like we were a normal family.

    Almost.

    Except for the fact that I knew when they left that I wouldn't see them again until someone else in the family died, or was deathly ill.

    That evening spent with them was magic to me, though. In that it broke the spell of my feeling that I was really missing out on something because they shun me.

    I realized that we have absolutely nothing in common anymore. Their belief system is so vastly different, their air of haughtiness and self-righteousness (the "we know the answers to everything" trademark JW attitude) is now too much for me to take. It's totally alien to me.

    I watched as they squirmed in my presence, trying to ignore how happy a household I have now (I suffered terrible depression in the years I was close to them) and I know that they kept asking themselves why, since I am not 'doing anything wrong', don't I ask to be reinstated.

    I was around them enough throughout Dad's illness to see them through new eyes. The clear eyes that I have now after being out of the Tower for so long. I've seen that their patterns of behavior have not changed. My cousins are going down the same destructive path I did when choosing my first husband: one of them just announced her engagement and I am actually relieved that I'm not invited to the wedding, instead of being beside myself with sorrow like I was when her sister married in 1998. I know that the marriage is a bad match. I don't think I could watch it even if I were invited. I don't feel like I'm missing out on anything.

    I don't feel envious now of my sister anymore, who is still in close contact with my cousins. They were once as close as sisters to me, but now they are such drones, incapable of an individual thought, and I know that it would do nothing but frustrate me to have to watch what they are doing. I know too much. I see them tap dancing on the tracks, blind to the light of the oncoming train. The same train that ran me over and nearly killed me.

    I wish I could save them the grief. That they would learn from my experiences and realize there is so much more to life than they have been taught. But they won't hear me. So I have come to terms with that, made peace with it, and for the first time, I'm all right with it.

    I know now that shunning has been a protection to me in that if they hadn't done so, I probably would have stayed a slave of the WTS. If they had been loving, forgiving, and reasonable at the time of my divorce instead of going along with the crowd in shunning me and not even asking why I did what I did, then I would have been sucked back in. With devastating consequences to myself, my child, and my new marriage.

    I have come to realize, that as sad as it was, their cutting me off has been one of the biggest blessings in disguise that I've ever gotten. Because I would have put up with their continuing emotional abuse of me, disrespect for my feelings, and all the JW baggage that goes along with that. (and we're not talking carry-on, folks!) Now, I don't. And even if they opened their arms up to me tomorrow, there would be new rules of behavior required for them to be in my life.

    If they ever leave the org, of course I will help them to work through the issues as best as I can. But I am no longer waiting for it, dreaming of it. They have made their choice, just as I have mine, and I know now that I can go on just fine without them.

    They look at me with such shock when they see that not only am I happy with my life, I'm perfectly fine with the fact that I'm disfellowshipped. It doesn't bother me, in fact, I rarely think of it unless someone brings it up.

    I am me, that's all. Their judgments can't touch me. I don't need their approval or acceptance to know that I'm a good person. And that annoys and confounds them to no end.

    To those of you newly struggling with the loss of family to disfellowshipping, I give you my sincerest sympathy and understanding. I've been there. Just hang in there and do whatever you have to do to be happy with your own life. To surround yourself with people who love and respect who you are, not what they want you to be.

    I feel so fortunate as the new year arrives to know that I'm free of it. I didn't know if I ever would be, but I am. And I wish the same for all of you in this situation.

    Life is too short to live as a slave to sadness. Being free... it's a feeling I can't describe. Such peace. And I know that as hard and hellish as it has been, I never would have gotten here if I hadn't been shoved out the door and shown the true nature of the organization.

    I hope that all of you can find peace for yourselves, too.

    Happy New Year Everyone!
    ~Esmeralda

  • LB
    LB

    Esmeralda I've been to your website in the past and think about you often. Interesting take you have there on disfellowshipping. How it's a protection for the DFed. I must agree, it makes sense to me that you may have been sucked back in without the shunning.

    Being free of the borg is quite the blessing.


    Never Squat With Yer Spurs On

  • Amazing
    Amazing

    Excellent Esmeralda! Your post reminds me of two sayings: Taking Lemons and making Lemon aide, or the more currently popular one of, "Seeing the glass, not as half empty, but half full." I appreciate you for this, and as always, enjoy your insights. Thanks. - Amazing

  • AMarie
    AMarie

    Excellent post. And as Amazing said above, you always have such a positive attitude about life and a lot of insight into situations, which are qualities that I would like to cultivate within myself.

    Also, it's funny that you said that being DF'd has been a protection for you because I was just thinking along those lines the other night. Since it has been many months since I've talked with my dear mother, I've been writing her a letter. And in it, I stated that disfellowshipping has been a great blessing to me because I have finally learned to give MYSELF unconditional love. Now that I don't hear meeting parts about how we need to do more, and now that I don't have people looking over my shoulder all of the time, I'm finally learning exactly who I am and what I like. Even though it was difficult in the begining, finding my "true self" without all of the rules and regulations of the WTS has been the most awesome experience of my life. I wouldn't trade what I've been through for the world.

    I'm glad to hear that you are experiencing as much happiness as I am.

    AMarie

  • Richie
    Richie

    Thanks Esmeralda for your revealing post where, as you stated, disfellowshipping is really a protection for all of us. Little do we realize at first, that by being thrown out of this unloving arrangement, it is actually for our benefit - NOT to go back to the Borg of course - but in order for us to compare genuine love with plastic love, the latter naturally referring to the Society.
    You correctly stated in one paragraph the full reason why it is beneficial for us to be shunned and at the same time recognizing that a come-back would be fruitless:

    "I have come to realize that as sad as it was, their cutting me off has been one of the biggest blessings in disguise that I've ever gotten. Because I would have put up with their continuing emotional abuse of me, disrespect for my feelings, and all the JW-baggage that goes along with that (and we are not talking carry-on, folks!) Now, I don't. And even if they opened their arms up to me tomorrow, there would be new rules of behavior required for them in my new life."

    I couldn't have said it better Esmeralda! Thanks for the wise words....so true!!
    A Happy New Year to you too!

    Richie :*)

  • Kristen
    Kristen

    Es,
    Enjoyed taking in your reflections. Happy New Year to you too!

    Kristen

    free to be me

  • myMichelle
    myMichelle

    Hiya, Es!

    What a positive and healthy way of looking at your situation.

    I was thinking of my own experience yesterday, and realized that I'm almost grateful for it. I have done a lot of growing up in the last few years, that's the best summary of it. I'm a better me than I was just 5 years ago, and I'm pretty sure that I wouldn't be at this stage had the WTS not intruded into my family.

    My marriage is better than ever and I cannot say if this whole WT involvement was necessary to evolve to this stage or not. My husband and I may have achieved this on our own, who knows? I won't be writing any thank-you's to the WTBTS, but I can see the pattern of growth that it influenced.

    Happy New Year Everyone too,
    Michelle

  • Mum
    Mum

    It's wonderful that you have this insight and perspective. It is a blessing when people show their true colors. Congratulations on rebuilding your life, and in record time!

    Seize the day, and put the least possible trust in tomorrow. - Horace

    I have learned to live each day as it comes and not to borrow trouble by dreading tomorrow. - Dorothy Dix

  • Mulan
    Mulan

    Hey, Essie! All I can say is "you've come a long way, baaabbbbeeee!!"

    Good job.

    Marilyn (a.k.a. Mulan)

  • Francois
    Francois

    Excellent post, very excellent post.

    As in all organizations like it, the Borg is running off its best minds. The parallels with the Third Reich are stunning.

    Francois

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit