Cultural Aspects of Spanking--Countries Other than US

by blondie 15 Replies latest jw friends

• 

  acsot

  Corporal punishment within the family (school corporal punishment is illegal here in Quebec):

  Date: January 2004

  Canada's Supreme Court limits but fails to remove parents' "reasonable force" defence

  By six to three, Canada's Supreme Court judges have strictly limited the legality of parental corporal punishment and ruled out school corporal punishment. But they rejected an application by the Canadian Foundation for Youth, Children and the Law that section 43 of Canada's criminal code should be struck down as unconstitutional. The judgment was issued on January 30 2004.

  The majority judgment ruled that section 43 only justifies "minor corrective force of a transitory and trifling nature." It ruled out "on the basis of current expert consensus", corporal punishment of children under two or over 12; degrading, inhuman or harmful conduct; discipline using objects such as rulers or belts, and blows or slaps to the head. And the judgment states that teachers cannot use corporal punishment, although they may use reasonable force to remove a child from a classroom or secure compliance with instructions:

  "Substantial societal consensus, supported by expert evidence and Canada's treaty obligations, indicates that corporal punishment by teachers is unreasonable."

  Section 43 of the Code, under the heading "Protection of Persons in Authority" provides that:

  "Every schoolteacher, parent or person standing in the place of a parent is justified in using force by way of correction toward a pupil or child, as the case may be, who is under his care, if the force does not exceed what is reasonable under the circumstances."

  School corporal punishment has been prohibited in Canada in state schools only in British Columbia, Quebec, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Yukon, Newfoundland, Prince Edward Island, Northwest Territories and Nunavut. The judgment implies that corporal punishment is now unlawful in all private and public schools throughout Canada."
• 

  blondie

  bttt
• 

  RichieRich

  Thanks for digging this out blondie, considering my recent thread.

  I don't know about anywhere besides the US, but here I know its bad.

  Actually, just among dubs.
• 

  blondie

  http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cache:kczSg0mngvcJ:www.nospank.net/n-j48.htm+spanking+france&hl=en

  Faut-il interdire la fessée? / Should spanking be prohibited? www.Famili.fr, August 27, 2002
  Translation: Tom Johnson

  ---

  Prohibited in most European countries, it is still in effect in France. The recent book The Truth Will Set You Free by Alice Miller is starting up the debate again.

  Swiss psychologist Alice Miller doesn't mince words. We parents are too quick to resort to spanking. It is a vestige of our own childhood, she explains. Aren't we all, come to think of it, from a generation where spankings were routine? Excessive as they may be, Alice Miller's remarks have enough merit to at least reopen the debate: should we outlaw corporal punishment?

  Violence begets violence Sweden, in 1979, was the first to ban spanking. Since then, the other Scandanavian countries followed suit, as well as Austria, Italy, and, most recently, Germany. In France, according to a poll conducted in 1999 by Sofres, 54% of parents still "often" give a spanking to their child. A practice which a growing number of doctors and psychologists are taking a stand against. It is a humiliating and completely useless act, they argue. Jacqueline Cornet, a doctor and founder of the group Eduquer sans frapper [To Bring Up Without Hitting], goes further: "A spanking, even lightly, creates a great stress in the home of the child, who gets used to this manner of violent communication and will have the tendency to reproduce it. Only a law will be able to change attitudes." At first, because it will force society to condemn corporal punishment unequivocally. Then because such a law has to be accompanied by an information campaign aimed at families. Only the government has the means to put it in place. "It's not about putting parents in prison for spanking," Jacqueline Cornet clarifies, "but helping them find other child-raising methods."

  It is in this spirit that on Sept. 27 of last year, the group Eduquer sans frapper officially asked the Senate for the creation of a ban on corporal punishment.
• 

  blondie

  Worldwide, eight states do not allow parental spanking (all of them in Europe): Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Austria, Finland, Italy, Latvia and Cyprus.

  Other countries making progress toward banning corporal punishment of children through legal and/or educational campaigns are Germany, Switzerland, Poland, Spain, Canada, New Zealand, Mexico, Namibia, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Jamaica, the Republic of Ireland, Belgium, Korea, and the United Kingdom (EPOCH-USA, 1999b).

  In the United States, however, corporal punishment of children in the schools is legal in about half the states, and "reasonable" corporal punishment of children by their parents or guardians is legal in every state except Minnesota (Bitensky, 1998). Prohibition of corporal punishment in family day care, group homes/institutions, child care centers, and family foster care varies according to state laws (EPOCH-USA, 1999b).

  http://www.stophitting.com/disathome/sureshrani.php
• 

  DannyBloem

  What I know about none western countries is that in general there is spanking, as it is mostly very normal in those cultures. But actually among the dubs it is better then outside.