Sometimes Race does matter...

by mrsjones5 41 Replies latest jw friends

  • mrsjones5
    mrsjones5

    or to be more specific genetics matter. I just heard a story on NPR about blood marrow donations among the black community, why it's so low and why it's desperately needed. Here's a few points that I thought were interesting about this issue:

    1. The database donors is eight million plus.

    2. In 2008, 40 percent of caucasians who didn't have a bone marrow match in their own family were able to receive a transplant through the national marrow donor program. The rate for African-Americans was 15 percent.

    3. One reason for the difference is that fewer black people sign up to be donors than white people.

    4. Experts say that African-American patients have more rare genetic makeups than caucasians because their genes tend to be more racially mixed. This makes finding a precise match that much tougher.

    I volunteered to be in the database back in the 90's. I don't know if I'm still on it but at this point I kinda doubt it. I'm thinking seriously of getting back on the datebase and I encourage all (black, white, asian, hispanic, and etc) to do the same. The more folks we have in the database the better.

    Here's the article and link:

    Blacks Face Bone Marrow Donor Shortage

    by HABIBA NOSHEEN

    When Jennifer Jones Austin was unable to find a bone marrow donor match, her family appealed to the public in ads shown in churches and on the Internet.

    Bone marrow transplants are often the only treatment for blood-related cancers. The treatment, however, is dependent on the patient finding a donor who shares a similar genetic makeup. In most cases, that means the match is found in someone of the same race. But the black community has a particularly tough time attracting donors.

    Shawn Austin sits in the living room of his home in Brooklyn.

    "She's beautiful in that picture," Austin says as he grabs a photo of his wife from on top of the piano. The picture shows an African-American woman with long straight hair, a slender build, and a mischievous smile. That was Shawn's 42-year-old wife last year. In September, Jennifer Jones Austin was diagnosed with leukemia.

    "You know my immediate thought was, I am going to lose my wife to cancer," Austin says. But he learned that there was one way to save his wife's life. Through a bone marrow transplant. The transplant would use the bone marrow cells of another person to replace Jennifer's cells.

    Siblings have a 25 percent chance of being a match. But Jennifer's siblings weren't a match. So the family turned to the National Marrow Donor Program with hope and optimism.

    Bone Marrow Donors By Race

    Because of their mixed heritage and lower donation rates, African Americans have a smaller pool to draw matches from than white donor seekers. However, unlike solid organ transplants, there is no waiting list for bone marrow and cord blood transplants because patients aren't competing for the same donor.

    Pie chart: Current breakdown of the National Bone Marrow Registry, by race

    Source: 2010 National Marrow Donor Program's Be The Match Registry

    Credit: NPR

    "We thought it was no big deal. It's a database of eight million plus — someone's gotta be a match. Well, when you're of color it's not that easy," says Austin.

    In 2008, 40 percent of caucasians who didn't have a bone marrow match in their own family were able to receive a transplant through the national marrow donor program. The rate for African-Americans was 15 percent.

    One reason for the difference is that fewer black people sign up to be donors than white people.

    But there is another barrier. Experts say that African-American patients have more rare genetic makeups than caucasians because their genes tend to be more racially mixed. This makes finding a precise match that much tougher.

    When Jennifer Jones Austin couldn't find a match, her family appealed to the public in ads shown in black churches and on the Internet.

    In the video, Jones Austin shares her story, "I and my family and my friends have been frantically searching for the last little while for a donor," she says.

    Experts say despite emotional pleas, blacks are resistant to donating and 38-year-old Akiim DeShay says he can relate.

    "That's a very, very deep issue in the black community and it really stems from having a mistrust of what a lot of African Americans consider the 'system,'" DeShay says.

    Genetic Diversity in African-Americans

    Of the millions of donors registered with the National Marrow Donor Program, about 8 percent are black and 75 percent are white. Because bone marrow compatibility is closely linked with race, that means blacks have a much smaller pool of potential donors.

    But even if that pool were much bigger, it would still be harder fob African-American people to find compatible donors than whites. That's because they tend to have a rarer genetic tissue type than whites.

    Finding a bone marrow match requires finding someone with the same tissue typing known as Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA). The more mixed a person's family heritage the harder it becomes to find someone with the same HLA typing.

    "African-Americans aren't purely Africans...they are really a mixture of an extremely broad and diverse group of different ethnic populations," says Dr. Willis Navarro, the medical director of the National Marrow Donor Program.

    "In African-Americans there are combinations of genetic identity molecules that don't commonly occur in more homogenous populations," Navarro says. "So that creates more genetic diversity and a more difficult match."

    Diversity in our genes is actually a very good thing that has allowed the human race to exist. That diversity in our genes ensures that if one group of people carries certain disease that the entire human race doesn't end.

    But when it comes to bone marrow, genetic diversity makes it that much tougher to find someone who is equally as unique as you are.

    -- Habiba Nosheen

    DeShay says given the way blacks have historically been treated by the health system it's no wonder they aren't rushing to do cheek swabs to have part of their DNA registered with the National Marrow Donor Program.

    "I recall I had the same feelings, so I never ever ever gave blood," DeShay says.

    But his own attitude changed in 2003 when he learned he needed a bone marrow donor or he would die.

    "My thing was, first of all, I don't know these people. They are going to be sticking me with needles. I just can't trust someone to stick me with needles," DeShay says.

    His sister's marrow saved his life. Now he spends his time recruiting other African-Americans to sign up through his websiteblackbonemarrow.com.

    In addition to the mistrust, many fear that being a donor is painful. But thanks to advances in science donating can be relatively pain-free.

    But with no match in the registry, Shawn Austin's wife, Jennifer, was running out of time, so doctors turned to a less desirable option.

    "Essentially I received cord blood from a newborn baby," she says.

    So, cells from umbilical cord that matched Jennifer's genetic makeup were used to save her life, an option with longer recovery times and sometimes the fear that cell supply might not be enough.

    "There have been days I've stayed on this couch from 9 o' clock in the morning until 5 o' clock," Jennifer says, as she sits on her beige sofa.

    Today, her face looks nothing like the photo on the piano. No longer do her long locks frame her face. Instead, just a few strands of tiny hair peek out from her bald head.

    "While I may be cured of leukemia, it is a life-long treatment process. I've got to find that place I can be forward-thinking but all the while be mindful of — that nothing's promised.

    Even though Jennifer wasn't able to find a bone marrow donor and had to settle for cord blood, she says she's already heard that of the 12,000 or so donors — mostly blacks — who signed up trying to save her life, there ended up being matches for other African-Americans who needed transplants.

    That, she says, makes her feel there was a higher purpose to her illness.

    http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=128173149

  • changeling
    changeling

    Interesting.

  • snowbird
    snowbird

    Thanks, Josie.

    So much more I could say, but that'll suffice.

    Syl

  • mrsjones5
    mrsjones5

    Don't bite your tongue Sylvia. Some folks want to fight about silly stuff but with something as serious as this I see no one has much to say. Well I got to step out, maybe there'll be more replies when I get back.

  • straightshooter
    straightshooter

    Very interesting statistics.

  • Soldier77
    Soldier77

    Well, to me a major problem looks like it's the lack of donor's. Yes, African-Americans (according to the article) have rare genetic make-up, but as more donors join in, the higher the chance of finding a match. I would think... That may be overly simple thinking and I'm sure there is much more to it than that, but you have to start somewhere.

    So in other words, become a bone marrow donor!

    (Side note: Is accepting a bone marrow transplant on the no-fly list of things JWs can do?)

  • snowbird
    snowbird

    Toward all.

    Syl

  • twinkle toes
    twinkle toes

    I think that the likely hood is that many black or mixed race people would donate. I don't know if I believe the bit about them being hesitant to participate. However, I do believe that there is very little time, effort or cash being spent in recruting these to become donors.

    The reflection of statistics is obvious to me that more resources have been put toward collecting donors for the white community. Not an unwillingness to help by people of color.

    tt

  • snowbird
    snowbird
    I don't know if I believe the bit about them being hesitant to participate.

    Believe me, the hesitancy is there.

    The Tuskegee Syphilis Project still looms large in many minds.

    Syl

  • beksbks
    beksbks

    I didn't even realize that it was race effected I thought we were all the same on the inside.

    Is this the wrong time to point out, that we need to stop focusing our resources on subsidies for the wealthy and war, and start thinking about what actually constitutes Life Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness for all Americans?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit