Potential New Article for JWFacts: Iglesia Ni Cristo

by ILoveTTATT2 16 Replies latest jw friends

  • ILoveTTATT2

    Paul has allowed me to write up two articles for JWFacts: Iglesia Ni Cristo, and Why Russell was not a Mason.

    Here is my Iglesia Ni Cristo article. Please let me know your thoughts on it:

    Similar Religions to Jehovah’s Witnesses: Iglesia Ni Cristo

    Iglesia Ni Cristo: Similarities and Differences with Jehovah’s Witnesses

    The Iglesia Ni Cristo is a church founded in 1914 by Felix Manalo in the Philippines. Since both Charles Taze Russell and Felix Manalo got their doctrines from Seventh Day Adventist influences, the doctrines of both religions have ended up being very similar.

    For example, both the Iglesia Ni Cristo and Jehovah’s Witnesses:

    · Believe that 1914 was the beginning of the Last Days

    · Don’t believe in the Trinity

    · Believe that the Holy Spirit is an impersonal force

    · Don’t believe in the immortality of the soul

    · Salvation not by faith, but by works

    · Baptism by immersion is necessary

    · Obey leaders unconditionally

    · Think they are the “one true religion”.

    · Think/thought at one point that their founders is the Last Messenger of Revelation.

    · Believe that missing meetings is a sin, based on Hebrews 10:24-25

    · Have church discipline that includes reproof and disfellowshipping

    · Eating blood is a disfellowshipping offence

    · Don’t celebrate Christmas, or Easter, or most holidays.

    · Don’t celebrate birthdays (Except the INC celebrates Felix Manao’s birthday)

    · Shun ex-members

    · They are a restoration of the original 1st century Christianity, counteracting the 4th century apostasy

    · INC approves of voting

    · Disfellowshipping for marrying outside the church

    · INC approves donating blood and receiving blood transfusions, but not eating blood.

    · INC members can join the military

    · INC members wear a uniform

    · INC members cannot dance or drink alcohol

    History of the INC

    The INC was founded on July 27th, 1914 by Felix Y. Manalo. Manalo had been searching for the correct teachings in many religions. He left the Catholic Church dissatisfied in 1902, then he went to Methodist, Presbyterian, and Seventh Day Adventist churches, before founding INC.

    Over the years, the church has grown to millions of members. It is unknown how many members there are, since the church does not publish member numbers, but it is estimated to be from 4 to 11 million members.

    The church has gone through two generations of successors: Felix Manalo died on April 12, 1963, and his son, Eraño Manalo, took over, until his own death in 2009. The current church leader is Manalo’s grandson, Eduardo Villanueva Manalo.

    In 2014, like the Jehovah’s Witnesses, they celebrated 100 years since 1914; the INC celebrating the 100th anniversary of the church, while the Jehovah’s Witnesses celebrated the 100th anniversary of “the birth of the Kingdom”.

    In 2015, there was a leadership controversy in which Eduardo expelled his brother, Angel Manalo, and his mother, Tenny, for trying to “create divisions”. Allegedly, up to 10 INC ministers were kidnapped and held at gunpoint. The Iglesia called it “disciplinary action”. The Philippine government is doing a criminal investigation on the church.


    The Iglesia Ni Cristo has the following beliefs, according to the site http://theiglesianicristo.blogspot.mx/2013/02/the-iglesia-ni-cristo-doctrines.html:

    About the Bible

    “We believe that the Bible is the word of God and the sole basis of our faith and service to God”

    About God

    “We believe that there is only one true God, the Father, and no one else besides Him”

    “We reject the unbiblical teaching that there are three person in one God – that aside from God the father, there is God the Son and God the Holy Spirit.”

    About the Lord Jesus Christ

    “We believe in Jesus Christ and accept Him as the Son of God, Lord, Savior, and the Mediator between God and Man”

    We reject the teaching that Christ is God.

    About the Holy Spirit

    “We believe that the Holy Spirit is the power that sent by the Father in the name of Christ”

    About the Messengers of God

    We believe that the late Brother Felix Y. Manalo is God’s last messenger, the fulfillment of the biblical prophecies regarding the “Angel” (“messenger”) from the east (cf. Rev. 7:2-3) who would preached to God’s sons and daughters from the “ends of the earth” (cf. Is. 43:5-6; 41:9-10; 46:11).

    About God’s Standing Policy of Election

    “We believe that God elects and set apart His people to serve Him”

    The Iglesia Ni Cristo believe that since the ancient times, God has set apart his people to serve Him (cf. Ps. 4:3).People outside this election are not God’s people (I Pet. 2:9-10, TEV), not of Christ, and without hope and without God (cf. Eph. 2:12).

    About Salvation and the Church

    “We believe that man must enter the Church Of Christ in order to be save come Judgment Day”

    Thus, faith alone is not enough.

    About Baptism

    “We believe that man needs to receive baptism to be saved and the baptism commanded by Christ and preached by His apostles is done through immersion”

    About the Church Administration

    “We believe that the Church Administration is from God and we are duty bound to submit ourselves to them”

    The Iglesia Ni Cristo believes that every member is duty-bound to submit himself to the Church Administration because it is God’s commandment:

    About the Christian Way of Life

    “We believe that those who are truly in Christ should live a righteous life based on moral teachings of the Bible”

    Those who are truly in Christ should lead a righteous life based on moral teachings of the Bible: “Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.” (I Cor. 6:9-10 NIV)

    We also believe that God prohibits the eating of blood (cf. Lev. 17:10; Acts 15:28).

    The Bible also strictly prohibits mixed marriage with unbelievers.

    About Worship of God

    “We believe that it is the whole duty of man to worship God and keep His commandments”

    Thus, the Bible strictly prohibits kneeling, bowing serving and worshipping graven images:

    The Christians are admonished by the apostles not to neglect their “church meetings”:

    About Brotherhood

    “We believe that members of the Church of Christ must love one another as brothers and sisters in Christ”

    The Iglesia ni Cristo believes that members of the Church of Christ should observe the brotherhood Christ Himself established the brotherhood inside the Church of Christ (cf. Mt. 23:8; John 13:34-35).

    That is why members of the Church of Christ address one another as brother and sister.

    About Christian Unity

    “We believe that it is God’s commandment that we must subscribe to sacred unity”

    Interesting Difference: Their Viewpoint on Blood

    Although the INC and the Jehovah’s Witnesses can both easily be considered a high control group that can be very damaging to member’s lives, they differ in the damage they cause.

    One of the most damaging doctrines of Jehovah’s Witnesses is their stance on blood. (Hyperlink to Blood article).

    The Witnesses believe that Acts 15:28-29, where it says “abstain from blood”, means abstaining from blood transfusions. This doctrine has led to many thousands of unnecessary and early deaths since its implementation in the 1940’s.

    INC members do not eat blood, based also on Leviticus 17:10 and Acts 15:28. But they correctly don’t consider (hyperlink to site that considers INC’s viewpoint on this… http://bagwisngagila.blogspot.mx/2012/04/on-birthdaysflag-and-blood-transfusion.html) Acts 15:28 to refer to blood transfusions. They say, simply, “this prohibition by God can not be used as a basis for forbidding the medical practice called blood transfusion, for "eating blood" is obviously different from "transfusing blood."

    So at least on this point, INC does not damage its members like the Jehovah’s Witnesses.


    There are many religions that are like Jehovah’s Witnesses. Usually, they are similar because they either are the Seventh Day Adventists, or the religion’s founders associated themselves with Seventh Day Adventists. There is a common thread of rejecting the trinity, holding “soul sleep” to be a true doctrine, holding that the Holy Spirit is an impersonal force, and focusing on time prophecies. This is a major part of the reason why INC and Jehovah’s Witnesses are so similar. Both INC and Jehovah’s Witnesses are considered a cult/high control group because of similar levels of control over believers’ lives.

    The official INC website is either http://iglesianicristo.net or https://incmedia.org/

    There are some ex-member websites, such as http://www.examineiglesianicristo.com/ and http://theiglesianicristoandfelixmanalo.blogspot.mx/

  • ILoveTTATT2

    Please ignore the formatting, it's impossible to fix... I fix it and then the page changes it back.

  • lusitano o tuga
    lusitano o tuga

    I already watched a sermon from this religion

    iglesia ni cristo......un filipino quasi-loco
  • Listener

    That's a good comparison. The only statement that I can see that is not correct is that both disfellowship for marrying a non believer. The JWs do not do this as a practice and will (generally) only mark an individual for dating a non believer.

    You may want to include how they are funded.

  • ILoveTTATT2
    The only statement that I can see that is not correct is that both disfellowship for marrying a non believer.

    I am sorry... the formatting of this page messed it all up. I had the statement of disfellowshipping for marrying a non believer as one of the DIFFERENCES, not the similarities.
  • ILoveTTATT2
    The article actually states:

    There are some differences between the religions:

    · INC approves of voting

    · Disfellowshipping for marrying outside the church

    · INC approves donating blood and receiving blood transfusions, but not eating blood.

    · INC members can join the military

    · INC members wear a uniform

    · INC members cannot dance or drink alcohol

  • ILoveTTATT2

    I guess I should change it to:

    INC disfellowships when members marry outside the church.

  • waton

    INC are strict tithers, not forking money over could be a disfellowshipping offence? Have the greatest public auditorium in the Philippines, (North Manila). have the most prolific Mormon-Utah- temple like churches all over the place ( I mistook them for a breakaway mormon sect). Vote in block, great political power.

  • Anders Andersen
    Anders Andersen

    ...and instantly that fucked up but really catchy children's cult song of INC pops in my head:

    Always submit to the church administration

    For they were placed by God over His nation

    Well at least they're honest and straightforward about it. Watchtower cult leaders try to say the same, but a little more obfuscated.

  • joe134cd

    Can I just add my 5 cents worth to the below statement

    Usually, they are similar because they either are the Seventh Day Adventists, or the religion’s founders associated themselves with Seventh Day Adventists.

    The SDAs and the JWs developed off the ideas of William Miller. They are similar in the sense that their roots can be traced to William Millar not that the founders were associated with the SDAs. The term adventist can also be used in a broad sense to mean a movement not a religious group. For example David Korash heavens gate community in Wacko Texas was a form of adventist.

Share this