A lion, a bear.
No one told them what they are. They didn't go to a class, read a book or listen to a PHD to tell them what they are.
Only a pseudo-atheist would need to have someone to tell him what he is, and he certainly would not join a religious discussion board, for there would be nothing to discuss.
Does he really need someone to tell him what he is? Does he need confirmation as to what he is?
I have know a few, very few, real atheists. It came from their heart. "What I want, when I want, with whoever I want, everything else be damned" attitude. No talk, just action.
There are no real atheists here, only the pseudo type.
NightOwl