Most are going to say run and don't look back. Easier said than done when love is involved. But there are reasons for why ex-JWs give you this advice.
Ask yourself some of these questions.
Do I admire this man for who he is?
Is this man going to protect me?
Is this man going to stick by my through thick and thin?
Is this man attractive when he talks about his religion?
Is this man confident enough in himself to make his own decisions, and make his way in this world?
Would this man be someone I would be proud to introduce to everyone I meet for the rest of my life?
Is this man going to be a great father, teaching his children to grow up and be incredible individuals?
What I am saying is to think long term here, if possible. Do you really envision yourself with this guy for the rest of you life, happier than you are now?