the mind of the exile

by teejay 4 Replies latest jw friends

  • teejay
    teejay

    In an Esquire magazine article entitled "End the Cuba Embargo, Now" Walter Mead makes a very good case that the American embargo of Cuba should end, and now. Not only would it help Cuba but it would strengthen America's position in the Western Hemisphere.

    As he makes his case, he draws the reader's attention to the powerful political alliance of Cuban Americans living in South Florida – primarily Miami. This coalition ("Miami") has had a stranglehold on American-Cuban foreign policy for thirty years, regardless of who lived in the White House. (Side note: Mead points out that this political bloc also had a hand in getting Bush elected in view of his tough talk toward Castro/Cuba as opposed to Clinton's more conciliatory tone.) Miami, he says, plays into Castro's hands in a variety of ways. At one point, Mead makes the statement that Castro "plays Miami like a violin."

    It's when he speaks of the politically active former Cubans now living in exile in America that he makes an interesting comment. He said:

    The first reason is that Miami politics is exile politics. Exiles everywhere
    always make the same mistakes: They consistently underrate the solidity of
    the regime they fled and exaggerate their own future role. Exile society is a
    hothouse of gossip, intrigue, and breathless rumors about imminent splits in
    the leadership, the imminent death of Castro, or some other miraculous
    development that will bring the whole ugly government down. Miami over-
    estimates its importance and the importance of the embargo to life in Cuba;
    after forty years of exiles and their-nine years of embargo, they still think that
    success could be just around the corner.

    I saw some interesting parallels that fit some ex-JWs. Not in total, of course, but some.

  • jst2laws
    jst2laws

    Teejay

    Excellent quote:
    “They consistently underrate the solidity of
    the regime they fled and exaggerate their own future role. Exile society is a
    hothouse of gossip, intrigue, and breathless rumors about imminent splits in
    the leadership, the imminent death of Castro, or some other miraculous
    development that will bring the whole ugly government down.”

    I would not want to discourage those who have worked hard and have sacrificed time and effort to research and distribute the truth about the “truth”. They have helped me, my family and countless others. But I hope unrealistic expectations do not result in devastating disappointment. I personally will continue helping individuals out of this mental captivity but I do not have any delusion about ‘bringing the WT down’. Any hope that destroying the WT is ‘just around the corner’ is as much a fantasy as ‘Armageddon’ is ‘just around the corner’.

    Jst2laws

  • TMS
    TMS

    teejay,

    Tremendous irony, here. The exile mentality not only fits ex-JW's, but also JW's, who are "alien residents".

    Just as ex-JW's exaggerate their impact on the Society, JW's overestimate their overall impact on society in general.

    Compare the commentary given following an assembly experience to the remarks after an ex has given their story. Both deal in hyperbole.

    TMS

  • VeniceIT
    VeniceIT

    OMG and I live near Miami!!!!!!!

    Ven

    "Injustice will continue until those who are not affected by it are as outraged as those who are."

  • teejay
    teejay

    TMS,

    I reread Mead's quote from the JW perspective you offered and you're right! I never saw it that way, but they both – JWs and exes – deal in hyperbole...

    ... while the big machine just keeps on churning.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit