Did Jehovah's Witnesses dishonestly insert the word "Apostate" in their custom version of the Bible

by Watchtower-Free 16 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • Watchtower-Free
    Watchtower-Free

    Interesting Article

    http://doctrinesoffaith.com/more-errors-in-jehovahs-witness-new-world-translation-bible/


    More Intentional Repeated Errors in New World Translation Bible: A Study on “Apostates”. Word Study: APOSTATE added to New World Translation.

    The Watchtower Society has modified words in the bible and replaced it with the word, apostate. By definition:

    This article will state the facts regarding more errors found in the New World Translation, which was released by Watchtower Society of Jehovah’s Witnesses in 2013. It will also examine the scriptures of the New World Translation version of 1961. Compare the scriptures for yourself using the resources provided, or other resources that you have available.

    Introduction & Background

    The Watchtower Society has modified words in the bible and replaced it with the word, apostate. By definition:

    Definition of apostate in English:

    noun

    A person who renounces a religious or political belief or principle.

    Source: Oxford Dictionaries

    The word “apostate” is referred to in a couple of different ways. The English dictionary refers to it as stated above. Others suggest that it refers to one who turns against God (to atheism). The Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that it means that a person “turned away from Jehovah”. However, one who turns away from God no longer has a belief in God.

    Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that if you leave their organization, you automatically leave God Himself. In essence, they are teaching congregation members that former Jehovah’s Witnesses are all atheists. What gives this away, is if you ask them if they believe that all former JWs are atheist, they will likely say, “they left Jehovah when they left ‘the Truth’ (they refer to themselves as ‘the Truth’, a term which Jesus assumed for Himself; “I am the Way, the Truth…”) because they liken their organization to a direct affiliation with God.

    So, in a nutshell Watchtower Society teaches: former JWs left God. (Atheist) However, many former Jehovah’s Witnesses actually can attest that they are nowhere in this category of having no belief in God. In fact, many have a stronger belief in God than they ever did as one of JWs.

    Changes in the Jehovah’s Witness Bible, The New World Translation: John 8

    It is no secret that there are numerous changes, replacements and omissions in the 2013 New World Translation. The most prominent being John 8:1-11 which has been completely removed. The Watchtower and JWs claim that this was a passage of debate, as some expert translators do note in their translations that this passage may not have been placed properly in this part of the bible. Rather, it may have belonged in another section, likely Luke.

    *1961 New World Translation: Begins John 8 with verse 12, but includes John 8:1-11 below the passage, and acknowledges that some manuscripts omit John 8:1-11. In this case, it is my opinion that this version of the NWT was correct in leaving the scripture placed where it is.

    The scripture has not been removed from other translations, due to the fact that most translators dare not violate Revelation 22:19 at the risk of being incorrect, and taking away from the word of the bible. The repercussion stated in scripture is losing out in heaven. The Watchtower, however, has ignored this scripture warning, likely because the Governing Body states that God personally directs them.

    Changes to New World Translation: Apostate

    The word apostate was used in the 1961 version, but then some of those scriptures were changed back again, as seen in the 2013 version.

    The New World Translation, intentionally added the word apostate to their bible in the following scriptures, taken from their website, which shows the 2013 version of the NWT. The 1961 Version also shows the word apostate in the passages below, as well as additional passages.

    Source: The New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures. (Scriptures spelled out below are copied from the JW.org website and do not match the clickable links of the scripture itself. Clickable links are provided by ESV Bible translation. Click the scripture link to see how the ESV version reads for each scripture.)

    Proverbs 11:9 By his mouth the apostate brings his neighbor to ruin, But by knowledge the righteous are rescued

    Isaiah 10:6 I will send him against an apostate nation, Against the people who infuriated me; I will command him to take much spoil and much plunder And to trample them like mud in the streets.

    Isaiah 33:14 The sinners in Zion are in dread; Trembling has seized the apostates: ‘Who of us can live where there is a consuming fire? Who of us can live with unquenchable flames?’

    Isaiah 9:17 That is why Jehovah will not rejoice over their young men, And he will have no mercy on their fatherless children and their widows Because all of them are apostates and evildoers And every mouth is speaking senselessness. In view of all this, his anger has not turned back, But his hand is still stretched out to strike.

    The word apostate is intentionally added into the above scriptures in the 1961 and 2013 versions of the New World Translation.

    * The 1961 New World Translation also injects the word apostate into:

    However, these scriptures are changed back in the 2013 New World Translation, correcting the word, and instead using “godless” or “ungodly”, as it should be translated. They did not, however, treat the scriptures in Proverbs and Isaiah the same way.

    A complete study was performed using 15 of the most common bible translations, including the most popular King James Version, New King James Version, New International Version, English Standard Version, Revised Standard Version, New American Standard Bible, and others. The 15 translations translate the word using the Strong’s H2611 word, chaneph which is actually properly translated in all 15 translations to be either:

    • hypocrite
    • godless
    • ungodly
    • profane

    The Jehovah’s Witnesses Watchtower Society has changed the word to say “apostate”, which is an entirely different meaning of the Strong’s H2611 word, chaneph, found 13 times in the King James Version, as well as the widely accepted most accurate translation, the NASB. What does this mean? Read the verses again. If the word is most commonly translated to “hypocrite” 13 times in the most accurate word-for-word version, then there is a reason that the Watchtower translated the word to imply a word used for former Jehovah’s Witnesses.

    If the JWs teach that former JWs have left God, then by changing their scripture, they reaffirm that former JWs are hated by God (even if they are Christians who love God). The Jehovah’s Witness Bible implies that anyone who leaves Jehovah’s Witnesses:

    With this being clarified, JWs have taken the word for hypocrite and likened it to an atheist, by their own terms. In the dictionary, a hypocrite is stated to be: (Source: Mirriam Webster)

    hyp·o·crite


    \ˈhi-pə-ˌkrit\noun

    : a person who claims or pretends to have certain beliefs about what is right but who behaves in a way that disagrees with those beliefs

    Strongs H2611

    Hypocrites pretend to have certain beliefs. Strongs H2611 also refers to Godless (atheist) or Ungodly (acting in a way that shows defiance against God). Nowhere does this word translate to apostate, (renouncing a religious belief).

    Also note: A religious belief is not the same as theology. Religion is not defined as the study of God. It is a belief in. Theology is the study of God.

    Apostate does not mean hypocrite.

    Apostate does not mean godless.

    Apostate does not mean profane.

    Apostate means to renounce a belief. Not to renounce God.

    The word Apostate was added by the Watchtower Society to these scriptures, where it does not appear in any other bibles that are readily found in the top 15 translations.


  • sowhatnow
    sowhatnow
    of course, and then they needed to alter all the other scriptures to fit that idea. its amazing the scriptures they changes claiming they mean the same thing. thanks for the list of scriptures too.
  • freemindfade
    freemindfade

    Fascinating... I would love to show this to some R&F, although as with most negative info about the org it worries me, how so?

    I would be willing to bet that in this lovely orwellian organization soon if you share things from the pre-2013 silver bible to show the deceit of the great publishing company of YHWH, you (ironically) will be deemed an 'apostate'

    el oh el...

    There are so many skeletons in the WTBTS closet that when you bring them up everyones knee-jerk reaction is screaming apostate and running the other way, maybe the pre-2013 bible will become another part of JW history that if you refer to it gets you labeled apostate, again, total irony with the OP.

    Nice find, thank you.

  • Splash
    Splash

    (Proverbs 11:9) By his mouth the apostate brings his neighbor to ruin

    (Romans 5:6) For, indeed, while we were still weak, Christ died for ungodly men

    These are both from the NWT, and highlight why you should be consistent with your renderings.
    The same Greek word is used in both of these instances, in one they are an apostate, and in the other Christ dies for them.

    Why they didn't translate Pr 11:9 the same as the other verses around it where that word occurs ("wicked") we can only guess:

    (Proverbs 11:5) the wicked one will fall
    (Proverbs 11:7) When a wicked man dies
    (Proverbs 11:8) the wicked one comes in instead of him
    (Proverbs 11:9) By his mouth the apostate brings his neighbor to ruin
    (Proverbs 11:10) when the wicked ones perish
    (Proverbs 11:11) the mouth of the wicked ones

    etc.
  • Watchtower-Free
  • Vidiot
    Vidiot

    @ Watchtower-free...

    It's funny...

    ...after I'd started to have doubts/issues (but before I started fading), the pointing and hissing by the pod-people in Invasion of the Body Snatchers was exactly how I visualized my JW associates reacting if I ever came clean.

  • OUTLAW
    OUTLAW

    Changes to New World Translation: Apostate

    Proverbs 11:9 By his mouth the apostate brings his neighbor to ruin, But by knowledge the righteous are rescued

    Isaiah 10:6 I will send him against an apostate nation, Against the people who infuriated me; I will command him to take much spoil and much plunder And to trample them like mud in the streets.

    .........................Image result for jw.org broadcasting

    Image result for Breaking news

    .

    .................THE BIBLE WAS WRONG SO WE CHANGED IT..
    ............................Image result for jw.org broadcasting

    .

    Revelation 22:19

    American King James Version
    And if any man shall take away from the words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take away his part out of the book of life, and out of the holy city, and from the things which are written in this book.


  • jwleaks
    jwleaks
    They did remove the phrase "mentally diseased" from the revised NWT.
  • sparrowdown
    sparrowdown
    How long before they replace the name Jehovah with ToMo of Armies.
  • Wonderment
    Wonderment

    Usually the English word "apostasy" is related to the Hebrew word "meshuvah," not "chaneph."

    The WT Society is apparently basing their English choice of "apostate" on the suggestions posted by Lexicon in Veteris Testamenti, by Koehler/Baumgartner (Page 317).

    In this Lexicon, they indicate the following relation to "chaneph" by defining it:

    "be polluted, be inclined away from the right relation to God."

    "pollute" .... lead to apostasy... alienated from God."

    The Gesenius Hebrew-English Lexicon defines the adjective as "profane, irreligious...oft. heathen, apostate." As a substantive: "godless man."

    Also, the Theological Wordbook of the Old Testament defines the word as:

    "be defiled, polluted, profaned, corrupt."

    "The core notion is of inclining away from right..."

    "The adjective denotes a godless man, a man who forgets God (Job 8:13) and lives in opposition to all that is right..." (Vol 1, p. 695)

    Therefore, the notion that "chaneph" can include the meaning of "apostasy" in some contexts seems possible. However, that does not mean necessarily that the NWT is justified to replace "godless" or "hypocrite" with this word. The Society appears to be pushing the pencil here in order to justify their repeated warnings to active JWs to stay away from "apostates."

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit