I want to thank everyone for their thoughts, contributions, and links to other discussions about this topic. I'll be staying home on the night of the 17th. Knowing that I won't be missed has made the decision easier. I think that the only people who should attend are those who intend to partake of the emblems. I must agree with those of you who believe that the entire ceremony is pointless unless one partakes. Otherwise, staying at home makes perfect sense. Why "observe" and "celebrate" something that has no personal meaning? Yet the WTS insists on all JWs coming to the meeting, listening to the talk, and then act as though they are actually very happy to be part of the function.
Nearly 20 million people will go to the Memorial this year. I wonder what the non-Witness or unbaptized person will make of the whole thing. Then there are those who come to the Hall only for this event. And, of course, there are those who are either disfellowshipped, disassociated, or have been publicly reproved and who come because they feel they must. They know their absence will be noted and be held against them when they ask for reinstatement or restoration of privileges.
My own personal take is that celebrating the Memorial no longer has any scriptural basis. I believe in Jesus' ransom sacrifice and how it will eventually benefit all mankind. I do not have a hope of life in heaven after death, nor do I believe that I am among those who will ever be chosen for this. I do believe that God will reward those who love him and keep the two greatest commandments his Son said we should. That has given my life meaning, and I still have the hope of a future under God's kingdom rule when that kingdom finally comes. But in rejecting so much of the WTS theology surrounding this, I have found that I am now free to walk my own spiritual path, and that is giving me much joy and satisfaction. My friends, I wish the same for all of you.
Quendi