How Jehovah's Witnesses Made Me an Atheist

by galactical 10 Replies latest jw friends

  • galactical

    This is a repost an anonymous user calling themselves theplutonian posted yesterday on reddit. Its long, but i think it will resonate with most here.

    Original Link

    I guess I’ve been waiting for an opportunity to tell my story, and this is as good a place as any. It’s long-winded, I know, but I usually tell people the short version. This is the long version.
    Before I begin, you should be familiar with the religion I’m going to discuss. Jehovah’s Witnesses. There are about 7 million of them worldwide. I’m going to come right out and call the religion what it is- a cult. I was a JW from birth until the age of 20, so I speak from experience. I was baptized and was active in the congregation for a long time.

    For those who didn’t click the link, I’ll give you a quick rundown of what JWs do that most religions don’t.

    -They don’t celebrate holidays and birthdays. My parents converted to JW when I was about two. That means that prior to my 21st birthday, I don’t remember ever celebrating my birthday or any holidays.

    -They don’t allow dating outside of the religion. I didn’t start dating until I was 20. Thank god I wasn’t socially awkward or warped in the head.

    -They strongly discourage having friends and a social life with those friends if they’re “worldly”, or not part of the religion

    -They strongly discourage their followers going to college (I’ll give you two guesses why)

    -They actively preach, knocking on your door on Saturday morning and wherever else they can find you

    -They don’t accept blood transfusions, believe that only 144,000 people are going to heaven, and a lot of other weird things. Suffice it to say that fun in general and anything that would make you believe in them less was discouraged

    -By the way, if you’re baptized and encroach on one too many of these things, you get disfellowshipped. This means that you can’t speak or interact with anyone from the church for about a year, until one of the elders deems you worthy, at which point you spend about two years trying to crawl back up the JW social ladder to wherever you ranked.

    I’m not quite sure how to describe the time I spent going to church, preaching, and generally being deprived of a lot of fun that most kids have. I had to go to church 3 times a week. Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Sundays. Saturdays amounted to two hours of preaching, which I dreaded. Saturday preaching was always in the mornings, which meant that my brother and I never got to watch cartoons. While other kids were watching Batman, we were out in the cold passing out magazines. Tuesday bible study lasted 1 hour. Thursday was 2 hours, Sunday was 2 hours.

    Take a second and think about that. On top of “preparing” for meetings (extensive study of the Watchtower publications), you had 7 hours of your week sliced out. Preparation included, it was probably about 14 hours. This was for 20 years. Imagine how much time I lost. Twice a year, we had conventions. They were the worst. Imagine being around 7,000 other JWs for a whole weekend. 8 hours in a convention center listening to old men talk about how great Jehovah is.

    As a kid, I tried so hard to convince myself that I enjoyed church and preaching, since that was how I was told to feel about everything. That’s the thing. I remember them telling us so often that we should enjoy the time we spent serving God, but my brother and I never really had fun doing that stuff. They brainwash their followers to feel a certain way, and to think a certain way.

    They even went so far as to tell us (constantly) that we shouldn’t play engage in any form of entertainment that was too violent/evil/sexual/magical/fun.

    My brother and I mostly ignored this advice, which was what kept us sane. To this day, I am glad that my aunt never really enforced the entertainment laws on us. We were able to feed our imaginations with vid games and books and movies. The kind of stuff that makes you dream about what life could be like. It’s all making sense to me now. If you’re running a cult, you don’t want people to have fun and dream about doing stuff that isn’t going to church.

    What was worse than losing massive amounts of time and being told not to have fun in the name of God was the people.

    Being a JW is like living in a fucked up utopia. Everyone’s smiling and pretending to be happy, but they really aren’t. The adults willingly signed up for the cult, but their kids didn’t. The kids are forced into this world. Many JWs were hypocritical and judgemental. Even when you were in the religion, there was an implied hierarchy of “holiness”. Some people just weren’t great JWs because they didn’t preach enough, or made too much money. They were a bit too “worldly”. A bit too “free thinking”. I think my brother and I fell into that category. We were bad cattle, because we were too smart. JWs have a passive-aggressive way of arguing and fighting with each other, and it’s nauseating.

    I started having doubts when I was in the ninth grade. I started questioning things internally. I wondered “what would I do if I was in a car accident and needed a blood transfusion? What’s going to happen when I become a senior in high school and wanna go to college? What kind of job am I going to have? Who will I marry? I don’t want to marry one of these frigid bitches who will be about as interesting in bed as a potato sack.”
    They didn’t want us to go to college. It would make us think for ourselves, and that’s bad, right? You wanna know what the alternative to college? Bethel service. It’s basically a place where you go and spend about 3 months up in New Jersey around other JWs praying and packaging Watchtower publications into boxes or cleaning toilets. That’s supposed to be the best thing a young man can do to serve god.

    My brother was a senior in high school when I was a sophomore. He decided he was going to go to the best university in the area. I encouraged him, and was really excited when he started attending. The congregation wasn’t too pleased. I remember some of the congregation making backhanded insults and jokes at him, as if he wouldn’t understand. I don’t think anyone in our congregation ever went to college. My brother and I were the first in our immediate family to go to college.

    When my brother started in college, he started to talk to me about his doubts. I remember the day he just came out and said it. We were preaching, and it was cold out. We would do what we usually did whilst preaching. Knock on the door. Pray that no one comes to the door. If someone comes to the door, bullshit until they shut the door. My brother confirmed suspicions and doubts I’d been having too. I was scared when my brother started telling me his doubts. I was still sort of scared of god, but I was more scared that he’d get kicked out of the house and be disfellowshipped from the church (as if that matters).

    My brother’s plan to leave the church was to fade out of existence. He left our church to transfer to another one, then slowly stopped going to meetings. Around this time, he moved out.

    I mustered up the courage to leave a year later. I told my aunt about how I felt about God. I told her that I believed in an energy source creating the universe, but I didn’t believe that he was personified. I don’t think she understood what I meant. I love her to death, but I don’t think she can even fathom why I don’t believe anymore. She took it well in the beginning, and then the arguments started. I’ve learned since then just to smile and nod whenever she challenges me with her weak arguments. Once she burst into my bedroom and yelled at me about how I should change my mind, or “I’ll be sorry”.

    “What’s that, a threat?” I thought. “That’s a GREAT way to get me to come back to the church, thanks!”
    I have never felt better in my whole life. I will be 23 years old in about a month. That means I’ve been out for almost three years. I can’t describe to you how good it feels to be me, and not under some invisible being’s grip.

    My 21st birthday was the first I ever celebrated. My brother bought me a drink as a present, and I’ll always cherish that. I celebrated my first thanksgiving this past November, and I just celebrated my first Christmas last week. It was great.

    I have so much more to talk about, but I think I’ll just end with these thoughts:
    I learned a lot of good core values from JW. I also gained a lot of reading and writing skills that most people don’t have. I met a lot of great people, and I appreciate that.

    Right now, I’m well on my way to graduating from a local university. I play, read, draw, watch, and write what I want. I feel proud of how I turned out, but I’m still afraid to admit to myself that I’m probably an atheist. I’m pretty much an atheist pretending to be an agnostic so that people won’t judge me. Weird, right? I think that’s whatever JW is left in me trying to maintain peace.

    I have recurring nightmares about being locked in JW churches against my will. It happens maybe once every two months. I wish there were more “recovering JW” support groups, because we really need it.
    Whenever I tell people this story, they know why I feel the way I do about god and religion. I wasn’t raised an atheist, but Jehovah’s Witnesses gave me a nice, firm shove in that direction.

    Thanks so much for letting me tell my long ass story. Send me a message if you have any questions or comments.

  • Curtains

    hi galactical, welcome to jwn. thanks for sharing your story.

  • galactical

    Thanks for the welcome. Not my story though. :-D

  • Curtains

    rightyO - lol - put my specs on now. thanks for sharing theplutonian's story and please invite him over, he'll get a lot of support here

  • Found Sheep
    Found Sheep

    Good for you! welcome and enjoy your life. Glad you have your brother

  • new light
    new light

    That was a good story that rang true. Being a JW kid was just f---ing horrible. I get that warm, fuzzy feeling reading about people catching on and making something of their lives at any age, but especially when they do so in time to go to university at the normal age. Thanks.

  • Namasti

    OH--I enjoyed your story so much. My story is very similar. You are not alone. We all have horrible stories like yours. I was much older when I finally woke up and left the JW's. So thankful for that. I went on a spiritual search for a long time and finally found my way. I wish the same for you. It's great that you can speak some positive words about your experience in the cult. It still is hard for me to say anything good. LOts of luck....Isa

  • God_Delusion

    Hi and welcome to JWN mate.

    As a JW, you are taught to care what others in the kingdom hall think of you and how they would judge you. Therefore, this is my advice; don't think badly if people disagree with you. Don't fuss yourself with what others think of you, unless it's your partner and/or children.

    I had a similar experience. I took the "Organisation's" advice and read the Bible daily. After covering the first few chapters of Genesis, I realised that the God of the Bible was as real as the Tooth Fairy and Frodo.

    I would love to post a version of your story on my blogs, and If you are interested, contact me via the sites, but I want you to let me know what is was that made you realise that you are an atheist.

    Live free man.


  • darth frosty
    darth frosty

    Great story!

    Its good no matter what age you get out, but I am always glad when people get out young enough to still be able to enjoy their youth!

  • factfinder

    Hi galactical!

Share this