The Watchtower vs Humanity

by JeffT 6 Replies latest jw friends

  • JeffT
    JeffT

    Yesterday my wife and I saw a production of Verdi's "Falstaff" - great opera. The production notes contained this comment, which got me to thinking.

    "Yes Falstaff is a scoundrel and yes, he ultimately gets his comeuppance, but Kazaras {the director} believes - if we're being honest with ourselves - that there is a little Falstaff in all of us. 'The concept behind the prodcution,' he says, 'is to remember that whether it's an audience member, whether it's an orchestra member, or whether it's a stage hand, or singer onstage, everybody is human. We all do the same great and stupid things, and anybody who denies it is a liar.'"

    The WTBS, with its endless rules, regulations, JC's, shunning etc is trying to eliminate that basic human condition from within its members. No one is allowed anything less than perfection - even this side of the Big A. The smallest infraction of the rules results in elimination from within the organization. But in an effort to eliminate the negative, they've destroyed the positive. A complete absence of hatred sounds worthy, but not at the simultaneous removal of love. They try to end sorrow and stop joy with the same sweep of rules. Where there is no chance of great failure, neither is there the possibility of great success.

    In an effort to make everybody the same, the WTBS has created a grey mass of mediocre sameness, a loss of identity, a destruction of their members God given right to be themselves.

    At least when people like Beksbks, and Farkel, and Bizzy Bee, and Burntheships, and Villabolo and I (among many) are throwing rocks at each other over some damn thing or another; we all know everybody's alive.

    I don't think the same could be said of a KH.

  • WTWizard
    WTWizard

    I have noticed that. If you feel positive about one person or family at the Kingdumb Hell, they expect you to feel the exact same toward everyone else. They will draw congregation, territory, and/or book study lines between you and anyone you dare become "too close" to, while sticking you on the same side with everyone you couldn't give a fxxx about. They do this every single time.

    Plus, there is zero tolerance for differences in beliefs. While there is disunity in some of the rules (some will allow driving to see the Christmas lights and others will not, for instance), everyone is expected to accept whatever the Filthful and Disgraceful Slavebugger puts out. No one is allowed to reason "Some of what they are putting out is rubbish, but they are around 85% accurate, so I will stay in for the 85% and disregard the 15% that is errant". Instead, you have to abide by and teach the 15% that is rubbish (which leads them to make it more like 85% rubbish, or more).

    This forum, on the other hand, has a wide variety of religious beliefs. And none of them are stifled. Many are active witlesses (some trying to leave, others trying to get us back). There are Christians of every variety. You have people that are atheists, Devil worshipers, Muslims, Hindus, other Eastern religions, and those who simply do not know what is the real truth. People like these will give their viewpoints, and others on the board will accept or deny those beliefs for themselves. And there are even arguments for and against these viewpoints. However, there is no policy where one has to believe in any one denomination in order to stay on board. Which is a lot more than can be said about the Kingdumb Hells.

  • Terry
    Terry

    Here is how I look at it.

    Humanity's only flaw is ignorance and lack of self-mastery.

    With complete understanding and self-discipline it would be smooth sailing (absent accident).

    Groups (society's, nations, etc.) come about to achieve a purpose otherwise unavailable to individuals because their strengths are multiplied and knowledge amplified by pooling and distilling the best from the worst.

    The Watchtower Society has it all backwards and inside out.

    Jehovah's Witnesses cannot ACHIEVE their stated Purpose of living on a Paradise earth or going to rule in heaven.

    Why? It is an imaginary purpose!

    The best the group (Society) can do is PRETEND through make-believe efforts that the purpose is an automatic EVENTUALITY and, by not dropping out of the overall effort, they'll be swept into the fulfillment.

    In short: treading water in a shark-infested ocean until a ship of rescue comes along!

    The obvious down-side to this Illusory Purpose is everybody will get exhausted and sink below the surface NO MATTER HOW LONG they tread water!

    When this drowning (attrition) takes place the Group must pretend the victim TIRED OUT due to lack of faith in the EVENTUAL PURPOSE!

    Nobody wins except by pretending they WILL eventually!

    The worst thing that happens while the entire group treads water relentlessly is voice a word of REALITY such as "Hey, nobody is coming to rescue us!" It would dishearten the entire group! So, the swimmer is made to float away and swim toward some distant shore.

    How did they all end up in the water in the first place? They boarded a ship named PARADISE, Watchtower Shiping Lines. The trip was supposed to be a very short one (Armageddon for everybody NOT on the ship). Instead, like Gilligan's Minnow incident, they met with a storm at sea (bad dates and faulty doctrines) and were castaway.

    In the Watchtower Org you don't even get to end up on an island! You just tread water for your entire lifetime unless you drown or get eaten by sharks.

  • nancy drew
    nancy drew

    something that really bothers me is the concept of whole souled expected to do your best its confusing to most because the wtbs defines it as "you can never do enough" live in a state of urgency it''s crazy people need to understand that everyone can pick up a heavy weight for a brief time but you can't continue you have to put it down thats normal. the best you can do in life is what you can maintain on a regular basis and still feel positive, rested, even. The org pushes people and makes one feel somehow inadequate and insists on feeling happy while performing useless tasks it eventually drives you crazy and you lose your humanity to yourself and others.

  • JeffT
    JeffT

    Terry, what you said reminds me of something my wife said a few years ago. Psychologists will tell that "I'll be happy when..." is a very dangerous state of mind. It is one thing to set a goal and work toward it. It is something else to think "I'll be happy when I loose weigh...or make more money... or buy a house... or get a hair transplant" whatever.

    What my wife said was that for JW's the new system is the ultimate "I'll be happy when..."

  • snowbird
    snowbird

    This is such a good topic.

    Sylvia

  • cantleave
    cantleave

    I better start throwing rocks at someone

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit