Bethel Memoirs, Good and Not So Good

by Room 215 18 Replies latest jw friends

  • Room 215
    Room 215

    In an earlier post, I mentioned a recent trip to a local Assembly Hall to catch up on the latest in JW rhetoric -- which incidentally sounds pretty much like it always has.

    While being regaled with exhortations to elevate the importance of meeting attendance to the status of that approaching a patient on life support, I couldn't help but chuckle as how so many -- not all, mind you, but many Bethelites during my tenure there in the late sixties, honed their skill at ducking meetings to the level of fine art.

    Because it was policy that work assignments took precedence over all other obligations including and especially meetings and field service, many would find some pretext to stay back and piddle away at their desk or workbench. This was particularly true of the stafers assigned to the maintenance of the Bethel home.

    For those assigned to weekend reception duty at 124 Columbia Heights, the building in which most of the higher-ups live, their first order of business on Sunday mornings was to go to the Hotel St. George newstand and pick up a bunch of Sunday New York Times, to deliver to the doors of bigshots like Knorr, Suiter, Couch, et al. Because these fellows so frequently lazed about the home, sleeping in, rummaging around the kitchen, etc, in casual clothes, we dubbed gthem ``the Ban-Lon'' brigade in reference to the polo shirts they favored on such occasion.

    Of course, none of this inhibited them in the least from intoning solemnly on the vital importance of regularity in meetings and service whenever they took to the podium.

    Or take the plight of anyone assigned to work on a project the Society deemed a top priority, such as the Watchtower Farm construction when I was there.

    When ordered to shape up to move up to the farm for the job, we were laughed at when asked about bringing along ``nice'' clothes for meetings and service. In short, all we encountered was wall-to-wall work, often through the weekends and onto the the following week, and absolutely no contact with the local congregation. About the only meetings we attended were an hour's family Watchtower study on Monday, which we attended in overalls or jeans.

    For such jobs, the Society would often call in to Bethel any special pioneer or circuit overseer who had specialized construction skillls. You should have seen the looks on their faces when their ovcerseers told them they wouldn't be excused from work just to go to a meeting or out in field service! (Wesley Benner, the CO who hounded Ray Franz, was one such guy). Many of these types proved to be as naive as the newest new person when it came to believing the Society's rhetoric about the sanctity of meetings and service.

    This is getting long, so I'll limit myself to two last reflections, real quick. You servants, remember you we're urged to be reliable? One time when assigned to pick strawberries at Mountain Farm on a Tuesday, it got late and we were not finished. We were sent back to pick after dinner by the headlights of several pickup trucks. When I requested to make a phone call to the book study to tell them I wouldn't show up to conduct, I was told to forget it.

    At the assembly, the dubs were urged never to submit to a boss's orders to overcharge or cheat in any way. I couldn't help but think that in almost 40 years of full time work, the only one who asked me to do something dishonest was my Bethel overseer (i.e. to hide several gallons of paint thinner which were over the allowed limit as a city inspectore was one his way to the shop). My roomate, who worked as a plumber, was once assigned as a lookout while others finished unlicensed plumbing work in the Greenpoint Avenue Assembly Hall.

    Of course, I still have many pleasant memories of the place, mostly of the comraderie and mutual commiserations of friends I made, many of whom turned out to be friends for life -- some still there, others out, loyal JW and ex-JW alike -- and for some of the dear, sincere older members of the family, now all gone.

    But I must say that it's rare for anyone to go through the Bethel experience and come out with his/her idealism intact.

    Thanks for listening (reading), whatever....

  • TweetieBird
    TweetieBird

    Thanks for sharing your experiences. I only visited Bethel, however, I did have a brother that was there for a couple of years. His experience shattered his belief system of the witnesses having the truth.

    We had Wesley Benner as a CO once, I didn't care for him. All of the pioneers and elders loved him. When he left, they threw a going away party for him and you were only allowed to attend if you were an elder or pioneer. Not even MS's were allowed. Caused a big stink around here, but that's typical behavior, such love for the nobody's in the cong.

  • Frenchy
    Frenchy

    I join with tweetie in thanking you for your experience. I have many fond memories associated with my congregation. Departure would be easier for me were it not for those.

  • Room 215
    Room 215

    Thanks Tweety, Frenchie...

    You can't imagine how self-conscious talking (or in this case writing) about myself makes me!
    Frenchie, your comments about old memories (and resumably, of friends) really resonates with me, as it does for so many others who participate on this forum.

  • metatron
    metatron

    This is an area most Witnesses know nothing about. The Society
    has done an excellent job of covering up over decades. I knew
    so many guys who lost all faith in the WT after years in Bethel.

    There's so many, many stories to tell. I heard of one C.O. who
    complained that ex-bethelites were often bad examples because
    they couldn't be pushed to do anything.

    metatron

  • Room 215
    Room 215

    Right on the money as usual Meta......

    Though there's no way of proving it, I'd bet any amount that the rate of dissent/disaffection is highest among former Bethelites ....by far.

  • bj
    bj

    Thanks for sharing your experense. Can you tell us please who was your Overseer who asked you to hide the paint?

    I remember when Milton Henschel came to Malta, in a whole week, he NEVER went on the service. No, he prefered to play the tourist and leave others do the dirty work!

    Joe

  • VM44
    VM44

    Room 215,

    Thanks for your posting! I did not find it overly long at all,
    in fact, I wanted to read even more about your experiences.

    I find the first hand Bethel experiences to be fascinating.

    --VM44

  • its_my_life2001ca
    its_my_life2001ca

    I've been reading "In Search of Christian Freedom" and Franz brought out how several members of the governing body rarely engaged in field service. Most didn't attend the book studies and didn't share in the group service activity, among them Knorr, Suiter, Fred Franz, and Henschel. I think of the poor brothers in the congregations who had to work long hours to support their families, prepare meetings and regularly participate in field service or suffer the consequences. Family life and any personal interests went by the wayside. As mentionned above, most brothers don't get in the travelling and visits to exotic places that the higher ups do...such a double standard...how can they expect God's approval on themselves or do they really care?

  • Prisca
    Prisca

    Room 215,

    I always enjoy reading your posts, and this one is no exception. Don't apologise for the length of it - it's worth it!

    Many of us have not had the opportunity to have worked in Bethel branches, especially the world headquarters in NY. Your insight and experiences are quite unique! Thank you for sharing them with us.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit