Arabic "We will not be silent" T-Shirt removed before flight

by Elsewhere 11 Replies latest jw friends

  • Elsewhere

    I saw a news article about this on the Al Jazeera news site the other day and was going to post about it here with a link, but I was not able to because they promptly removed it. Perhaps it was because of my post I made on their site about the article. Many people, mostly from the Middle East, were posting about how hateful America is for making him take off his t-shirt before boarding the flight... but I pointed out the following:

    If he had worn a controversial t-shirt while waking down the street in a Middle Eastern country, he would likely have been mobbed, tourchured and executed in the streets.

    They didn't like it when I pointed that out.

    Denied Boarding for Wearing an Arabic T-Shirt: Meet Raed Jarrar

    Raed Jarrar is an Iraqi architect living in the United States. He was forced to change his t-shirt recently at New York's JFK airport because the Arabic script on it was apparently making other passengers uncomfortable. Here is his story, as he reported it on his blog on August 10.

    The next day, I went to JFK in the morning to catch my Jet Blue plane to California. I reached Terminal 6 at around 7:15 am, issued a boarding pass, and checked all my bags in, and then walked to the security checkpoint. For the first time in my life, I was taken to a secondary search. My shoes were searched, and I was asked for my boarding pass and ID. After passing the security, I walked to check where gate 16 was, then I went to get something to eat. I got some cheese and grapes with some orange juice and I went back to Gate 16 and sat down in the boarding area enjoying my breakfast and some sunshine.

    At around 8:30, two men approached me while I was checking my phone. One of them asked me if I had a minute and he showed me his badge, I said: "sure". We walked some few steps and stood in front of the boarding counter where I found out that they were accompanied by another person, a woman from Jet Blue.

    One of the two men who approached me first, Inspector Harris, asked for my id card and boarding pass. I gave him my boarding pass and driver's license. He said "people are feeling offended because of your t-shirt". I looked at my t-shirt: I was wearing my shirt which states in both Arabic and English "we will not be silent". You can take a look at it in this picture taken during our Jordan meetings with Iraqi MPs. I said "I am very sorry if I offended anyone, I didnt know that this t-shirt will be offensive". He asked me if I had any other T-shirts to put on, and I told him that I had checked in all of my bags and I asked him "why do you want me to take off my t-shirt? Isn't it my constitutional right to express myself in this way?" The second man in a greenish suit interfered and said "people here in the US don't understand these things about constitutional rights". So I answered him "I live in the US, and I understand it is my right to wear this t-shirt".

    Then I once again asked the three of them : "How come you are asking me to change my t-shirt? Isn't this my constitutional right to wear it? I am ready to change it if you tell me why I should. Do you have an order against Arabic t-shirts? Is there such a law against Arabic script?" so inspector Harris answered "you can't wear a t-shirt with Arabic script and come to an airport. It is like wearing a t-shirt that reads "I am a robber" and going to a bank". I said "but the message on my t-shirt is not offensive, it just says "we will not be silent". I got this t-shirt from Washington DC. There are more than a 1000 t-shirts printed with the same slogan, you can google them or email them at [email protected]. It is printed in many other languages: Arabic, Farsi, Spanish, English, etc." Inspector Harris said: "We cant make sure that your t-shirt means we will not be silent, we don't have a translator. Maybe it means something else". I said: "But as you can see, the statement is in both Arabic and English". He said "maybe it is not the same message". So based on the fact that Jet Blue doesn't have a translator, anything in Arabic is suspicious because maybe it'll mean something bad!

    Meanwhile, a third man walked in our direction. He stood with us without introducing himself, and he looked at inspector Harris's notes and asks him: "is that his information?", inspector Harris answered "yes". The third man, Mr. Harmon, asks inspector Harris : "can I copy this information?", and inspector Harris says "yes, sure".

    inspector Harris said: "You don't have to take of your t-shirt, just put it on inside-out". I refused to put on my shirt inside-out. So the woman interfered and said "let's reach a compromise. I will buy you a new t-shirt and you can put it on on top of this one". I said "I want to keep this t-shirt on". Both inspector Harris and Mr. Harmon said "No, we can't let you get on that airplane with your t-shirt". I said "I am ready to put on another t-shirt if you tell me what is the law that requires such a thing. I want to talk to your supervisor". Inspector Harris said "You don't have to talk to anyone. Many people called and complained about your t-shirt. Jetblue customers were calling before you reached the checkpoint, and costumers called when you were waiting here in the boarding area".

    it was then that I realized that my t-shirt was the reason why I had been taken to the secondary checking.

    I asked the four people again to let me talk to any supervisor, and they refused.

    The Jet Blue woman was asking me again to end this problem by just putting on a new t-shirt, and I felt threatened by Mr. Harmon's remarks as in "Let's end this the nice way". Taking in consideration what happens to other Arabs and Muslims in US airports, and realizing that I will miss my flight unless I covered the Arabic script on my t-shirt as I was told by the four agents, I asked the Jet Blue woman to buy me a t-shirt and I said "I don't want to miss my flight."

    She asked, what kind of t-shirts do you like. Should I get you an "I heart new york t-shirt?". So Mr. Harmon said "No, we shouldn't ask him to go from one extreme to another". I asked mr. harmon why does he assume I hate new york if I had some Arabic script on my t-shirt, but he didn't answer.

    The woman went away for 3 minutes, and she came back with a gray t-shirt reading "new york". I put the t-shirt on and removed the price tag. I told the four people who were involved in the conversation: "I feel very sad that my personal freedom was taken away like this. I grew up under authoritarian governments in the Middle East, and one of the reasons I chose to move to the US was that I don't want an officer to make me change my t-shirt. I will pursue this incident today through a Constitutional rights organization, and I am sure we will meet soon". Everyone said okay and left, and I went back to my seat.

    At 8:50 I was called again by a fourth young man, standing with the same jetblue woman. He asked for my boarding pass, so I gave it to him, and stood in front of the boarding counter. I asked the woman: "is everything okay?", she responded: "Yes, sure. We just have to change your seat". I said: "but I want this seat, that's why I chose it online 4 weeks ago", the fourth man said " there is a lady with a toddler sitting there. We need the seat."

    Then they re-issued me a small boarding pass for seat 24a, instead of seat 3a. They said that I can go to the airplane now. I was the first person who entered the airplane, and I was really annoyed about being assigned this seat in the back of the airplane too. It smelled like the bathrooms, which is why I had originally chosen a seat which would be far from that area.

    It sucks to be an Arab/Muslim living in the US these days. When you go to the middle east, you are a US tax-payer destroying people's houses with your money, and when you come back to the US, you are a suspected terrorist and plane hijacker.

  • mkr32208

    He was in the right. The United States is becoming a disgrace. Who CARES what would happen to you in an islamic country! We shouldn't judge OUR freedoms by the way those animal behave! OUR country is based on freedom and his were taken away! I hope his settlement is in the MILLIONS!

  • Arthur

    I do see your point elsewhere, but just because other countries stifle free speech, doesn't mean the U.S. should also. I do understand that unbridled, and unlimited speech is something that none of us can expect to have, but I think that a T-shirt is something totally benign and trivial. I felt that this was a gross overreaction on the part of the security personnel.

  • HappyDad

    During WW II, Japanese Americans were sent to dention camps. They lost their businesses and homes. It didn't matter if there were four generations with the first one coming to the U.S. 100 years ago and they had no ties whatsoever to Japan. They were put behind barb wire anyway. Once the war was over they had to fend for themselves and start over. Now I'm not sure if any of their property was returned to them or not. However, I do know a Japanese American who is now about 81 years old who joined the U.S. Army at the time. He didn't even speak Japanese.......nor did his parents who had a business that they were taken from and incarcerated. After the war, they were not given anything back at all. To this day, my friend George (Japanese last name) still has some bitterness about it but he went on with his life and is still a proud American. In my opinion, what happened to them was a disgrace It never should have happened, but it was the fear and mindset of the time. It was WAR! we have Arab Americans experiencing just a fraction of the distrust that was shown to the Japanese Americans and some bleeding hearts are complaining. It's a shame that INNOCENT Arabs have to put up with this type of bullshyte, but it is a fact of life that this is going to continue here in the U.S. Who knows when something will happen and the government find out that many Mosques in this country are hiding places for weapons?

    So far....other than Timothy McVay and a couple of other domestic terrorists........the largest problem has been the bombing and killing......not only in the U.S., but also in middle eastern terrorists who happen to be Muslim. Since that is the case, none of them in this country on a green card should have a right to wear what our citizens might consider offensive, nor even the right to question those in authority who question them.

    Have they or any of their Imams condemned the actions of their fellow believers? One of these days, a family member or membors of all the bleeding hearts will be killed by these type of people. When that day comes, let's see if they still think the same. is still WAR and it all sucks!


  • purplesofa

    FYI: Raed is shown at the conference that came about when the women taking part in Troops Home Fast of Code Pink were invited to break bread in Jordan with members of the Iraqi parlament and political representatives of various leaders in Iraq.


    Give Peace a Vote! What if millions decided to vote their conscience and said 'No More War Candidates'? The Voters Pledge makes visible a powerful political force, the peace vote, a force that politicians cannot continue to ignore. It sends a clear message to the hawkish minority that leads both major parties to end the occupation of Iraq and to end unprovoked attacks on other nations. Sign the Voters Pledge and ask at least 10 of your friends to sign as well. Let's put PEACE at the top of the ballot in 2006!

    Weekend Inspiration! "Give us the truth! We are here today to insist that our news media live up to its sacred responsibility to ascertain and report the truth - rather than acting like nothing more than a bulletin board for the lies and propaganda of a manipulative, dishonest federal government," said Salt Lake City Mayor Ross C. "Rocky" Anderson at a peace rally on Bush's visit to SLC on August 30th. Click here to read his speech "Challenging the Culture of Obedience," and here to watch the action! It looks like the mayor's speech may have struck a chord with MSNBC's Keith Olbermann, who can be seen blasting Rumsfeld and the Bush administration on his show! Also, don't forget to check out Helen Thomas's article, "Democrats Need To Be Real Choice On War."

    CODEPINK Activist Retreat! Over 150 women gathered in Austin for our first national CODEPINK Retreat, and it was more AMAZING than we could have imagined! We shared 4 days with amazing women like Cindy Sheehan, Anne Lamott, Rhiannon, Molly Ivins, Rha Goddess, Diane Wilson, and the cofounders of CODEPINK. A diverse offering of workshops and break-out sessions helped us sharpen our skills, gather more inspiration, and empower our voices and our hearts. The power, beauty and authentic voice of each participant was heard and acknowledged, creating an atmosphere of trust and friendship that everyone felt. Click here for details and photos!

    TROOPS HOME FAST! On July 4, we launched an historic hunger strike, TROOPS HOME FAST in Washington, DC in front of the White House. While many Americans expressed their patriotism via barbeques and fireworks, we're fasting in memory of the dead and wounded, and calling for the troops to come home from Iraq. We're inviting people around the world to show their support for this open-ended fast by fasting for at least one day. Read an interview with Diane Wilson to learn more. Please sign here to to support us and encourage your friends to do the same. Click here to view photos,read our blogs and messages from the fasters!

    Join Camp Democracy, Sept. 5 - 21! Join us in D.C. for the entire duration of the CODEPINK-sponsored Camp Democracy, or for culminating activities on Sept. 20th: Women for Peace Day, sponsored by CODEPINK and the National Organization for Women. This event includes a history workshop led by Howard Zinn. For more info, click here.
    Declaration of Peace!
    We urge you to sign The Declaration of Peace, a pledge to take action against the war during September 21-28 if a peace plan is not established by that time. Declaration signers will take part in nonviolent action, marches, rallies, demonstrations, interfaith services, candlelight vigils and other creative ways to declare peace at the US Capitol and in cities across the US. Click here to sign the Declaration and learn more.
    CODEPINK arrested for Firing Karl Rove! A couple dozen war protestors created a bit of a ruckus at the Renaissance Austin hotel Saturday night during a fundraiser featuring presidential advisor Karl Rove. One of the CODEPINK protestors was Tiffany Burns, a press spokesperson for anti-war mom Cindy Sheehan."The police made it really clear to me that their objective was to get us out of the reception so we wouldn't bother Karl Rove while he was speaking,? Burns said. ?Rather than let us, find some peaceful resolution and leave after we said what we came to say." Click here for more.
    Visions of Peace Garden in Crawford, Texas! Thanks to many members of CODEPINK who responded to our alert and supported the transformation of dirt into Paradise, or as Cindy said, Kansas into Oz. In less than 24 hours members of the Camp Casey 3 community and the gals from CODEPINK created the Visions of Peace garden. At the entrance to Camp Casey 3 you are greeted with an explosion of pinkness, it catches your breath and inspires you. At the front of the garden on a bed of volcanic rock are the piles of children?s shoes to signify all the innocent lives lost in Iraq, Lebanon and Israel." Click here for more and see photos.
    Wings of Justice Award for Medea!CODEPINK Cofounder Medea Benjamin received this week's Wings of Justice Award from BuzzFlash for "pulling the fire alarm for peace." According to the award citation, "No one ever accused Medea Benjamin, co-founder of Global Exchange and CODEPINK, of being a shrinking violet. So it didn?t surprise us that it was Medea who interrupted the speech of the Iraqi Prime Minister to a joint session of Congress. She rose in the galleries and shouted, 'Iraqis want the troops to leave, bring them home now! Listen to the Iraqis!' Of course, she was speaking the truth to power, but was arrested anyway." Congratulations Medea!
    Middle East Peace Trip!CODEPINK cofounders, Medea Benjamin, Gael Murphy and Diane Wilson continued from Jordan to Beirut where they have been working with Lebanese activists and humanitarian aid groups to help those stranded without aid in South Lebanon. The cofounders fed 500 children in the parks of Beirut on Friday and are spending their days in meetings to learn how we can best help. Click here to read their blogs and see photos, and explore our brand new section: Let Peace Live.
    Support War Resisters! For the first time in the Iraq war, an officer in the U.S. Military, Lt. Ehren Watada, has publicly refused orders and will be brought to court-martial this summer. Click here for ways to show your solidarity and here to read a letter from Carolyn, Ehren?s mom, and find out more about his case. You can also support Army Specialist Suzanne Swift, who suffered sexual harassment at the hands of her commanding officers and refused to return to Iraq. Click here for more info.

    Mothers Declare Peace on Mother's Day! CODEPINK's 24-hour Mother's Day peace vigil was an amazing soulful, painful and joyful gathering. Cindy Sheehan, Susan Sarandon, Patch Adams, Dick Gregory, and Iraqi and Iranian mothers joined with mothers and others from all over the country to create a magical pink presence at the White House. Click here to see the media coverage & video, read our blogs and see the most beautiful photos imaginable! And click here to see reports from solidarity events that happened around the country.

    Support Iraqi Women: The US invasion of Iraq has moved Iraq from a secular to a more religious -- and violent -- society where women?s rights are being curtailed. Read our report Iraqi Women Under Siege and recent articles about women in Iraq. Click here to see the blogs, photos and media articles of the Iraqi Women?s Tour to the US. Donate to our efforts to support Iraqi women.

    Women -- & Male Allies -- Say NO To War! Sign here to join women and men from around the world who are coming together to SAY NO TO WAR. We are creating a massive movement crossing generations, races, ethnicities, religions, and borders to pressure our governments, the United Nations, the Arab League, and others international leaders to negotiate a political settlement to the war in Iraq.

    Listen Hillary! The American people are saying, "Troops out,"Iraqi people are saying, "Troops out." Are you listening, Hillary? CODEPINK has launched a nationwide campaign against Hillary Clinton because of her opposition to immediate troop withdrawal from Iraq.We have been tailing the senator around the state and the country to persuade her to oppose the war. Our protests in Chicago, Washington D.C, and New York have generated a buzz in the media. Check out our new website, for more info, and read Nancy Kricorian's latest article on Bird-dogging Hillary!

    Bring Our Guard Home Now!
    With over 70,000 National Guard troops deployed to Iraq, our homefront has been left vulnerable in the face of natural disasters like Hurricane Katrina. In response, CODEPINK is working with a coalition of peace groups to seek the immediate withdrawal of all National Guard troops from Iraq. At least twelve states are petitioning their governors to bring home our Guard! Click here to find out how you can join this effort and start a working group in your state!

    Local Spotlight! See our local CODEPINK groups in action! Our local spotlight showcases CODEPINK actions and events from around the country and the world.

  • ronin1

    I am really sorry this happened.

    My husband and I take Jet Blue all the time when visiting our previous State of New York. I am really shocked at Jet Blue's actions and I hope this Raed Jarrar sues and gets a nice settlement.

    People are becoming extreme and too paranoid.....they are not using good sense or good's getting out of hand.............


  • SixofNine

    oh wow, this guy's blog, "Raed In The Middle" has been a great source of perspective for the past several years.

  • purplesofa
    oh wow, this guy's blog, "Raed In The Middle" has been a great source of perspective for the past several years.

    Seems to me, they really picked the wrong person to mess with.

  • Nathan Natas
    Nathan Natas

    I agree with Elsewhere.

    In the USA, Raed Jarrar has the right to wear any tshirt he wants. He also has the right to walk from Florida to New York wearing his favorite tshirt.

    He displays little of the understanding that he demands for himself. Rights are for him, Him, HIM!

    The airline is a private business, and they have rights too, as do the other travelers on the plane.

    Boo-hoo-hoo! Poor Raed! I'll bet his new free tshirt was really scratchy too!

  • DanTheMan
    DanTheMan we have Arab Americans experiencing just a fraction of the distrust that was shown to the Japanese Americans and some bleeding hearts are complaining.

    Would you like to go back and live in the WWII days when this sort of thing was much more acceptable as evidenced by the said treatment of Japanese Americans? Go right ahead bro. I like things better as they are now, and it's the boo-hoo bleeding hearts that keep things moving, albeit begrudgingly, in the right direction freedom-wise.

    God help a country when the bleeding heart sensitive types are marginalized and demonized. Fascism-berg, straight ahead!

Share this