Fear of knowledge

by daystar 11 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • daystar
    daystar


    Over the weekend, these thoughts occurred to me:

    As a JW, we were always told to stay away from alternative (to the WTBS pubs) reading materials. The reasoning was that we could (would) be influenced by this reading material into believing what we read.

    At first I scoffed at this. But as I thought about it more, isn't this true? JWs are not taught to study any sort of material with a critical eye. They are taught to accept what they read in the WTBS material without much question. If a person is taught to digest reading and "study" material in this way, their instructor would be wise to limit their reading and study material, if control is to be maintained.

    So, into us was built a fear of external forces manipulating our minds, because the WTBS wanted this monopoly all to itself.

    Today, I can read a book without fear that, even should the author have ulterior motives, I will be forced against my will to believe something that I don't want to. I can read a book and afterwards say to myself, "What utter b*llsh*t!" and move on. And from the reading, though, gain knowledge about things I would not have otherwise. And I am a much stronger person, in this way, than I ever was as a JW.

    In this way, among others, the WTBS keeps its constituents in the Dark, keeps them weak, all the while proclaiming to be the source of Light.

    2 Corinthians 11:13-15 (New International Version)
    13 For such men are false apostles, deceitful workmen, masquerading as apostles of Christ. 14 And no wonder, for Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light. 15 It is not surprising, then, if his servants masquerade as servants of righteousness. Their end will be what their actions deserve.
  • carla
    carla

    I have tried to discuss this topic with my husband. I consider it a weak faith if simply reading a book could change your beliefs so drastically. Or even walking into another church or service. Could one go to say a Hindu service and be influenced and completely abandon your own faith? I suppose, but then what would that have to say about your own convictions? He of course can not see any of it.

  • Narkissos
    Narkissos

    Very interesting topic.

    What are "we" exactly apart from "influences"?

    The metaphor of "spiritual food" is a perversely clever one, concealing the obvious by making it even more obvious (à la E.A. Poe): JWs are influenced, by WT literature, to "choose" the WT influence as the only good one and fear other influences. If something doesn't happen to break the circle it can go round and round forever.

  • daystar
    daystar

    Narkissos

    What are "we" exactly apart from "influences"?

    This is something I've also been considering more lately. I suspect that the "we" you mention might be something similar to a soul, or inner self, perhaps. This self that, when awakened, is empowered (individuated?) to choose its influences rather than simply being moved to and fro by them without any knowledge of them.

  • diamondblue1974
    diamondblue1974


    I know I witter on about this but it is precisely why the organisation does not support higher education; they simply dont want their members to cast a critical eye over the contents of their publications. There is no room for an alternative view with regards to the society.

    Like you though I am glad I now have the ability to decide for myself what is good reading and what isnt.

    Accept nothing, question everything!

    DB74

  • stillajwexelder
    stillajwexelder

    I have only come here seeking knowledge,

    Things they would not tecah me of in colllege

    "Ring around my finger" The Police

  • garybuss
    garybuss

    In sales the first thing we learn is: "The confused mind always says no!". So our job as closers is to remove all confusion. The Society knows this. The recruiter tries to remove ALL "confusion". The elders don't want anybody "confusing" the other workers.

    The only problem is somebody forgot to tell the Society's book and pamphlet writer.


  • MerryMagdalene
    MerryMagdalene

    I think that was one of the main "mistakes" my mother made in raising me (she has often asked me where she went wrong)--she had such complete faith in her "faith" that she was not afraid of knowledge.

    She taught me how to read before I went to school, taught me the use of dictionaries and encyclopedias and concordances from an early age, and gave me free access to all the older publications (and my family had lots of them--everything from the 1920s on).

    These were some interesting tidbits I came across while researching yesterday, if applied to the WTS itself:

    Who

    Molds Your Thinking?

    "NO ONE tells me what to think! And no one tells me what to do!" Saying that so emphatically usually means that you have great confidence in yourself and in your own judgment. Is that how you feel? Understandably, no one else should make up your mind for you. But is it wise to reject so quickly what might turn out to be good advice? Can no one at all ever help you to make wise decisions? Anyway, can you really be sure that someone is not, in fact, molding your thinking, without your even being aware of it?

    Prior to the second world war, for example, Joseph Goebbels, Hitler’s propaganda minister, took control of Germany’s film industry. Why? Because he realized that this would give him an extremely powerful weapon with which he could "influence people’s beliefs and hence their behaviour." (Propaganda and the German Cinema 1933-1945) You are probably aware of the chilling effectiveness with which he used this and other means to manipulate ordinary people—normal, rational people—to follow Nazi philosophy blindly.

    The fact is that how you think, and hence how you act, is always influenced in some way by the feelings and views of those to whom you listen. This need not be a bad thing, of course. If these are people who have your interests at heart—like teachers, friends, or parents—then you will get great benefit from their counsel and advice. But if they are people who have only their own interests at heart and who are themselves misled or corrupted in their thinking, "deceivers of the mind," as the apostle Paul described them, then beware!—Titus 1:10; Deuteronomy 13:6-8.

    Thus, do not become complacent and think that no one could ever influence you. (Compare 1 Corinthians 10:12.) Most likely it is already happening—more frequently than you might care to admit—without your even noticing. Take the simple example of what product you decide to buy when you go shopping. Is that always a purely personal, rational decision? Or do other people, often unseen, subtly but powerfully affect your choice? Investigative journalist Eric Clark thinks they do. "The more we are bombarded by advertising," he says, "the less we notice, and yet, almost certainly, the more we are affected." He also reports that when people are asked how effective they feel advertising is, "most agree that it works, but not on them." People tend to feel that everyone else is vulnerable, but they are not. "Alone, it seems, they are immune."—The Want Makers.

    Squeezed

    Into Satan’s Mold?

    Whether you are influenced by everyday advertising may not have serious consequences. There is another influence, however, that is much more dangerous. The Bible clearly shows that Satan is the master manipulator. (Revelation 12:9) His philosophy is basically the same as the thinking of one advertising agent who said that there are two ways to influence customers—"by seducing them or by conditioning them." If propagandists and advertisers can use such subtle techniques to mold your thinking, how much more skilled Satan must be at using similar tactics!—John 8:44....

    Know

    What Is Going On

    In the main, such insidious forces will influence your thinking only if you let them. In his book The Hidden Persuaders, Vance Packard made this point: "We still have a strong defence available against such [hidden] persuaders: we can choose not to be persuaded. In virtually all situations we still have the choice, and we cannot be too seriously manipulated if we know what is going on." That is also true of propaganda and deceit.

    Of course, to "know what is going on," you must keep your mind open and receptive to good influences. A healthy mind, just as a healthy body, needs to be well nourished if it is going to function properly. (Proverbs 5:1, 2) Lack of information can be just as lethal as misinformation. So while it is true that you need to protect your mind from misleading ideas and philosophies, try not to develop a jaundiced and cynical view of all advice or information offered to you.—1 John 4:1.

    Honest persuasion is not the same thing as hidden propaganda. The apostle Paul certainly did warn the young man Timothy to be on the lookout for "wicked men and impostors [who] will advance from bad to worse, misleading and being misled." But Paul added: "You, however, continue in the things that you learned and were persuaded to believe, knowing from what persons you learned them." (2 Timothy 3:13, 14) Since everything you take into your mind will influence you to some degree, the key is ‘knowing from what persons you learn things,’ to be sure that they are people who have your best interests at heart, not their own....

    ...w99 4/1 20-22 "Who Molds Your Thinking?"~Merry
  • daystar
    daystar

    merry

    Yes, and a devout JW simply can't use that reasoning critically towards their own set of beliefs, informed to them by the WTBS, because that would be "apostate thinking".

    I really suspect that a lot of the crap that infiltrates any well-meaning religion is unconscious, until and unless some person(s) with devious motives takes control.

    There are more than a few spiritual leaders that insist that the purity of their teachings, such as they are, will only remain as such for all too brief a time.

  • Narkissos
    Narkissos
    This is something I've also been considering more lately. I suspect that the "we" you mention might be something similar to a soul, or inner self, perhaps. This self that, when awakened, is empowered (individuated?) to choose its influences rather than simply being moved to and fro by them without any knowledge of them.

    The mechanism of choice is complex indeed.

    Education to freedom has to provide, not only access to multiple sources of information, but also critical tools to assess the information, analyse the levers of propaganda (including the emotional ones) and (perhaps even more importantly) insight into one's own unconscious motives to adhere to, or reject, this or that type of thinking.

    When this is done we might either stop at some mysterious core of "free self" being the ultimate subject of knowledge and decision -- or find out that there is actually nobody left to decide anything...

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit